Eyedea
The Legend Continues
I love Lowry, and I agree that he's arguably better than Butler offensively. But Butler is also elite defensively while Lowry has slipped a bit. And, to boot, we have better depth at PG than at SG, so he's probably a better fit.
If we look at RPM:
2017-18
Butler (28): 3.61orpm, 2.78drpm
Lowry (31): 4.15orpm, 1.03drpm
2016-17
Butler (27): 4.82orpm, 1.80drpm
Lowry (30): 4.70orpm, 1.18drpm
2015-16
Butler (26): 3.12orpm, 0.89drpm
Lowry (29): 5.12orpm, 1.70drpm
2014-15
Butler (25): 3.87orpm, 0.43drpm
Lowry (28): 2.58orpm, 1.25drpm
2013-14
Butler (24): 0.90rpm, 1.23drpm
Lowry (27): 3.84orpm, 0.41drpm
I don’t know. Their defensive FG% rates have a negligible difference and Lowry’s perimeter defence and ability to move someone off the line is kinda better (according to NBA.com’s tracker, idk other reports). Butler is elite at deflecting passes and really good at recovering loose balls (Lowry’s up there too), but Lowry is arguably the best in the league at drawing charges and is one of the better guards when it comes to screen assists.
I’m just not one that thinks the Raps are a better team if the one for one swap is made. Especially in the locker room. If Butler comes here, I need Lowry to be here to not let things get out of hand.