Elliot has a shot and skating. He's just as bad as Cumiskey in other departments.
People just seem to forget that it was Elliott's strength that inhibited him, not his positioning. He actually tried to be in the right place and similar to Barrie last year/early this year had trouble keeping his positioning on the ice.
Um. Wouldn't that then make your "ceiling" = to sea level? Which is kind of low….
If that is Elliott's ceiling, my ceiling is Neptune, God of the Sea.
Ahahaha. But the world is 71% water. Look at how long sharks have been able to survive. Plus I get all the mermaids I want. I need my mermaid love.
Few players could skate like Kyle Cumiskey.
I have a feeling the Avs are never going to see Elliott's top potential as a member of their organization. Either they're going to send him down again and lose him to waivers, or they're going to keep him as a 7th/8th defenseman and kill any continued development. Or they could trade him, of course.
The only other possibility is him making the Avs' top 6 on the blueline, but I don't see that as terribly likely. He'd have to have a monster camp, or someone else would have to get hurt.
The problem with talking about Elliotts potential is that the gap between ability and potential is so massive that at age 23 potential becomes almost irrelevant.
Potential only means something if you have a chance to reach it. When it comes to Elliott it's better to speak of more tangible things such as the tools he has (skating, wrist shot, decent vision and passing).
As for Barrie vs Elliott. From the first ten games of each Barrie was that player that stood out. Not because he was more ready. I'm not sure he was but because of the combination of fearlessness/confidence and instincts. Those are things you have or you don't. He's been jerked back and forth by both Roy and Sacco and he still never is afraid to jump up in the play when he gets a chance.
The problem with talking about Elliotts potential is that the gap between ability and potential is so massive that at age 23 potential becomes almost irrelevant.
As for Barrie vs Elliott. From the first ten games of each Barrie was that player that stood out. Not because he was more ready. I'm not sure he was but because of the combination of fearlessness/confidence and instincts. Those are things you have or you don't. He's been jerked back and forth by both Roy and Sacco and he still never is afraid to jump up in the play when he gets a chance.
Sacco once tried to convince us all that barrie was the 8th man on the depth chart behind stalwarts Zanon, SOB, Quincey
Some of us still believe in Elliott having a higher offensive season than Barrie. Is that such a bad thing?
Not at all. But "Elliott having a higher offensive season than Barrie" is different than "potential to be one of the best offensive defensemen in the NHL".
In any case, it would be really nice to see Elliott begin to realize his potential this season though.
On playing for Patrick Roy:
“It’s great. I think everybody gets to see the fiery passion that he has and get to see him go off the wall sometimes, but he’s good with us. You can tell he’s put his time in in juniors and he’s a really good coach. He never loses his cool with us. I think the great thing about him is you can tell he’s a really smart hockey person. He’s always making adjustments during the game and he’s got a good demeanor.â
Good interview with Barrie.
http://www.nicholsonhockey.com/worthreading/2014/9/8/avs-barrie-recounts-roy-boudreau-incident
You can tell from that quote that Barrie really likes the kinder, gentler approach from coaches. Most players do, I think, but some guys do really well with a fiery coach (Roenick, Jokinen with Keenan)
I get the sense that players like a fiery coach at first, but they get tired of it really quick when the team is not doing so hot. Fire and passion then turn to anger and screaming. Maybe that's just college though with nothing but basically kids on the roster.
That's why Patty has the perfect demeanor IMO. He's a player's coach, and he doesn't yell and scream at the guys, but when he talks, he's intense and passionate so he captures everyone's attention.
Usually players coaches are more soft spoken, and guys end up tuning them out a bit because there isn't as much accountability. There's plenty of accountability with Patrick because he's going to let the players know about every detail, and you can't really tune him out because of his inflections when he talks, and how passionate he sounds.
Combine that with being one of the smarter hockey minds in the business, his head coaching experience from 8 years behind the bench in junior, and his storied HOF career that instantly gains respect among players by itself, and I don't think you could have a better combination of traits for this new era of coaching.
That's why Patty has the perfect demeanor IMO. He's a player's coach, and he doesn't yell and scream at the guys, but when he talks, he's intense and passionate so he captures everyone's attention.
Usually players coaches are more soft spoken, and guys end up tuning them out a bit because there isn't as much accountability. There's plenty of accountability with Patrick because he's going to let the players know about every detail, and you can't really tune him out because of his inflections when he talks, and how passionate he sounds.
Combine that with being one of the smarter hockey minds in the business, his head coaching experience from 8 years behind the bench in junior, and his storied HOF career that instantly gains respect among players by itself, and I don't think you could have a better combination of traits for this new era of coaching.