His point totals look good, although they have been tailing off significantly since his hot start.
Nothing else about his game has looked good for the past 15-20 games. Most nights he is visible, only as a defensive liability. His lack of versatility in our lineup is really hurting our ability to alter our line combos. He's just not very good without Kessel, and they're not even very good when they're together.
Kessel needs to be sheltered at ES. He is horrible defensively, and it makes Bozak look worse when Phil goes cold. If they're going to stay together, Carlyle needs to severely cut their ES ice-time and try to match them against 2nd and 3rd lines and D pairings as much as possible.
I'm not sure breaking them up is a viable solution, because Bozak looks terrible without him. He has basically zero offensive output, and still isn't strong defensively.
A fair discussion. My main point there was that Bozak is not "useless" as the claim seems to be.
I honestly don't know if we have enough "Bozak without Kessel" evidence to say he couldn't be used elsewhere effectively. His play away from Kessel was, for the most part, restricted to a faceoff specialist and not much else.
JVR-Bozak-Kessel is a line that excels on the powerplay and off the rush, and it's in these two places that it should be used. Carlyle can always go back to them should the Leafs need a goal, for example.
To me, the Kessel line looked its best at even strength when it had Winnik on it. It actually clogged the neutral zone and played the counter-attack.
I'd like to see this explored more. I know changing up the lines/chemistry when you are on a hot streak is difficult to justify, but after a 3 game skid I think it's time for Randy to shake it up a bit and balance the lines a bit more.
Do I expect it to happen? No. Both Wilson and Carlyle keep going back to that line as an all in "rush" line (which has its uses, but for a team with bottom of the barrel possession stats and needs to cut its GA, this needs to be tried I think).