- Jun 24, 2012
- 83,947
- 151,370
We could debate every one of those moves... Like I said, his past performance doesn't look great. He's learning the ropes on the job and that doesn't bode well for us.
It does bother me as well that MB has not had any longstanding tenure at any of the management positions he held. I much prefer the portfolio of someone who was an understudy for 5 plus years as an assistant-GM. MB tried to make up for his shortcomings by assembling a League of Ex-Goon Lackeys. Who knows how much of their judgment was left impaired by undiagnosed concussions.
Again, cautiously optimistic that we'll see improvements going forward but he's got to start making net positive moves rather than bad or questionable ones. Turning down big overpriced FAs with bad contracts is great, but he's got to do more than that for us to win. Let's see what happens with Bouillion... if he re-signs him, then that's scary.
Biggest issue as I see it was how far off the charts the Habs were, pre-MB, in terms of what most teams have set-up as a minimal blueprint for success. With so many holes in terms of qualified overseers, player procurement deficiencies in both expertise and manpower, disjointed decision-making, the reliance on too few individuals at key positions, the perceived need to have an ex-Hab player in management to foster some kind of "winning tradition" -- MB had to build the organization from the ground up.
He did identify the deficiencies, jury is still out as to whether he addressed them with the right individuals. Also, his whole mantra about building through the draft is highly desirable, but he's on a short self-imposed cycle to deliver success.
To peg the team's fortunes on prospects while the teams keeps earning draft picks within the bottom third of every draft, will require the services of oracle to assist Timmins. Bottom line, I don't think MB can do it with the draft or even a combo of the UFA market and the draft -- he's got to learn to trade and trade well.
Especially if he really does want to build through the draft, the irony will be for him to trade in order to secure better draft selection slots than his team is likely to warrant based on their foreseeable regular season performances.