Proposal: Tor-Ana Nylander for Montour swap

[405Exit]

Both teams can benefit from each other. Both teams have needs for both players. Im curious on opinions and wanting a HF board generalization of fair trade.

Top 6 Center for Top 4 RHD that is mandatory in this league,

Click to read more...

 

[loyaltotheend]

No from Toronto.

Would much prefer to just keep Nylander

 

[WTFMAN99]

Toronto gets bent over.

 

[A1LeafNation]

No

 

[Yamazaki]

Not fair. Leafs decline, not sure about the ducks.

 

[Leafs87]

Toronto isn’t trading Nylander or Marner and how is this close to fair? This screams Hall-Larson 2.0.

We aren’t that desperate to get a d man

 

[Halla]

hell no. leafs laugh and hang up . this is awful.

you arent getting Nylander unless you are willing to cough up Lindholm/Fowler.
Dude would have been your 2nd leading scorer

 

[405Exit]

Toronto isn’t trading Nylander or Marner and how is this close to fair? This screams Hall-Larson 2.0.

We aren’t that desperate to get a d man

Boards say otherwise? Leaf fans keep making proposals for other teams RHD. I just saw one of y’all ask for dumba in a new proposal. This is a fair trade and a fair swap.

 

[Halla]

Boards say otherwise? Leaf fans keep making proposals for other teams RHD. I just saw one of y’all ask for dumba in a new proposal. This is a fair trade and a fair swap.

well so far 86% disagree and the only one who thinks its fair is you

mods lock this up before it gets ugly

 

[Bryanbryoil]

I actually thought this was close to a fair trade, I guess we'll see what Nylander signs for though before declaring one >>> the other.

 

[TT1]

Nowhere near fair, Nylander is worth much more..

 

[Bryanbryoil]

IMO depending on Nylander's contract, Anaheim adds something else to even out the value.

 

[405Exit]

I actually thought this was close to a fair trade, I guess we'll see what Nylander signs for though before declaring one >>> the other.

Thank you. I appreciate it. Finally someone posts who isn’t biased and over gloating about prospects and potential.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Nowhere near fair, Nylander is worth much more..

Montour is a pretty damn good player, Nylander is very good but Montour is far from chopped liver.

 

[Halla]

Thank you. I appreciate it. Finally someone posts who isn’t biased and over gloating about prospects and potential.

salty much?

so the 80+ % voting are biased, but the one guy who agrees with you isn't? bye now

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Thank you. I appreciate it. Finally someone posts who isn’t biased and over gloating about prospects and potential.

RHD are a premium and Montour is a solid guy that will be entering his prime soon. That said centers are also a premium so the last determining factor for me will be their contracts.

 

[Tweaky]

Not a TOR fan, and I think they tend to overrate Nylander, but in this case, they are right to say no. Maybe not the horrendous overpayment they think it is, but is is lopsided enough to say no to.

 

[Marshy]

Would rather wait for Liljegren

 

[Bryanbryoil]

salty much?

so the 80+ % voting are biased, but the one guy who agrees with you isn't? bye now

Anaheim was the team that knocked us out of the playoffs and is a team that I frankly do not like so yeah I'm biased alright.

 

[Juicy Pop]

I'd stand pat if I were Anaheim. Keep that amazing blue-line intact and see what you have in Steel/Jones/Terry/etc. while monitoring the Kesler/Eaves situation.

 

[Halla]

Anaheim was the team that knocked us out of the playoffs and is a team that I frankly do not like so yeah I'm biased alright.

didnt say you were. just pointing out the flaw of saying everyone who disagrees with him is biased but the one guy who agrees isn't

i'd love for the leafs to acquire montour. not at the cost of nylander though.

 

[imjustzach]

At current value, I think Nylander-Manson is the closer 1 for 1 swap. It's not a trade I'd do as the ducks without an add from TOR but value in a vacuum, it'd be closer than this.

In a couple years, Montour's value might get there (depending on how much better he and Nylander get) but right now he just doesn't have enough NHL track record to fetch Nylander w/o adding.

Tbh, there's just not a good fit since Manson is the RHD TOR needs but also the RHD ANA can't afford to lose.

 

[405Exit]

RHD are a premium and Montour is a solid guy that will be entering his prime soon. That said centers are also a premium so the last determining factor for me will be their contracts.

That’s where I was getting at. I really appreciate your post. Top 6 center for top 4 RHD that’s a premium. We know how much top 4 RHD have been costing this year. Look at Ducks transaction regarding Vatanen.

 

[WTFMAN99]

I actually thought this was close to a fair trade, I guess we'll see what Nylander signs for though before declaring one >>> the other.

IMO depending on Nylander's contract, Anaheim adds something else to even out the value.

Thank you. I appreciate it. Finally someone posts who isn’t biased and over gloating about prospects and potential.

If Anaheim wants to ask us about Nylander then Manson or Lindholm's names need to come up in the conversation, otherwise it's a strong no.

I also realize that Anaheim isn't in any hurry to trade those 2 players either. I am just trying to give you an idea on the expectation of a return for Nylander would be. We wouldn't want Montour or Montour+ filler for Nylander.

 

[Jordan Belfort]

I’d do this but instead build the package around Kapanen, 1st for Montour