Top-50 NHLers at this point?

[ToastedFlower*]

Taking into account recent performances but also historically. My list;

1. Sidney Crosby
2. Erik Karlsson
3. Connor McDavid
4. Patrick Kane
5. Evgeni Malkin
6. Drew Doughty
7. Victor Hedman
8. Carey Price
9. Duncan Keith
10. Alex Ovechkin
11. John Tavares
12. Tyler Seguin
13. Ryan Getzlaf
14. Steven Stamkos
15. Matt Murray
16. Nikita Kucherov
17. Vladimir Tarasenko
18. Braden Holtby
19. Jamie Benn
20. Sergei Bobrovsky
21. Brent Burns
22. Roman Josi
23. Kris Letang
24. Nicklas Backstrom
25. Artemi Panarin
26. Oliver Ekman-Larsson
27. PK Subban
28. Alex Pietrangelo
29. Patrice Bergeron
30. Shea Weber
31. Anze Kopitar
32. Jonathan Toews
33. Aleksander Barkov
34. Filip Forsberg
35. Phil Kessel
36. Brad Marchand
37. Ryan McDonagh
38. Ryan O'Reilly
39. Leon Draisaitl
40. Claude Giroux
41. Henrik Lundqvist
42. Mark Scheifele
43. Ryan Suter
44. Johnny Gaudreau
45. Blake Wheeler
46. Cory Schneider
47. Nathan MacKinnon
48. Corey Crawford
49. Joe Pavelski
50. Mark Giordano
HMs; Lindholm, Vlasic, Perry, Hall, Dubnyk, Eichel, Matthews, Fowler

Kane isn't top 5 let alone top 10, he's a winger who scores. He doesn't play defense. The fact Matthews was left off after proving he can play against top lines night in night out, something Kane doesn't do after a decade career. Blake Wheeler Giroux Schnieder Holtby shouldn't be on the list.

Lindholm over all of them, Matthews it between 40 and 50. Lundy also isn't anywhere near the Lundy of two years ago, dude is in the decline stages. Get off NHL17 and stat sheets and actually watch a game!

 

[Maplebeasts]

I'm sure you're objective and non-emotional in your opinion

I'm sure you can do better than that.Where am I wrong? Does ranking those guys there and having Pastrnak where he is and the others mentioned above them make sense?

 

[DaPhazz]

1. Erik Karlsson
2. Sidney Crosby
3. Connor Mcdavid
4. Roman Josi
5. Victor Hedman
6. Evgeni Malkin
7. Patrick Kane
8. Marc-Edouard Vlasic
9. Nicklas Bäckström
10. Drew Doughty
11. Duncan Keith
12. Nikita Kucherov
13. Brad Marchand
14. Kristopher Letang
15. Brent Burns
16. Carey Price
17. Ryan Suter
18. Steven Stamkos
19. Vladimir Tarasenko
20. Artemi Panarim
21. Mark Giordano
22. Joe Pavelski
23. Braden Holtby
24. Alex Pietrangelo
25. Ryan Getzlaf
26. Oliver Ekman-Larsson
27. Sergei Bobrovsky
28. Alexander Ovechkin
29. PK Subban
30. Anze Kopitar
31. Leon Draisaitl
32. Phil Kessel
33. Blake Wheeler
34. Mark Scheifele
35. Auston Matthews
36. John Tavares
37. Claude Giroux
38. Ryan McDonagh
39. Patrik Laine
40. Evgeny Kuznetsov
41. Jonathan Toews
42. Henrik Zetterberg
43. Filip Forsberg
44. Matthew Tkachuk
45. Jack Eichel
46. Jakub Vorácek
47. Mats Zuccarello
48. Tyler Seguin
49. Johnny Gaudreau
50. Anton Stralman

Top 20

Canada 10
Russia 4
Sweden 3
USA 2
Switzerland 1

Top 50

Canada 20
USA 9
Russia 9
Sweden 7
Switzerland 1
Slovenia 1
Germany 1
Finland 1
Norway 1
Czech Republic 1

Anton Stralman better than Shea Weber?

 

[VoluntaryDom]

I screwed my list up a bit I'll make a new one later

maybe