top 10 enforcers in the nhl

[Islesfan24]

1. Orr
2. Godard
3. Avery
4. Gillies
5. Thornton
6. Carkner
7. Shelley
8. Konopka
9. Scott
10. Ogi Oglethorp

 

[Wheatking]

1. Orr
2. Godard
3. Avery
4. Gillies
5. Thornton
6. Carkner
7. Shelley
8. Konopka
9. Scott
10. Ogi Oglethorp

In what world is Avery an enforcer? Nevermind top 3?

 

[Islesfan24]

I thought we were talking about fighting skill. I shouldnt have put avery up there. He gets his ass wooped

 

[Darrelle Lundqvist]

1. Orr
2. Godard
3. Avery
4. Gillies
5. Thornton
6. Carkner
7. Shelley
8. Konopka
9. Scott
10. Ogi Oglethorp[/QUOTE]

Seriously?... and I'm a Ranger fan

 

[straka91*]

I thought we were talking about fighting skill. I shouldnt have put avery up there. He gets his ass wooped

It happens. Only top 10 avery should be in is the agitator category. And he is easily top 3.

 

[southerncross116]

I don't know that Scott doesn't only accept appointment fights too, though -so I wouldn't probably put him in the top 10.

If he did, or initiated some 'non-appointment' type scraps then it might be a different story.

 

[Mikachu93]

1. MacIntyre
2. Engelland
3. Godard
4. Orr
5. Thorton
6. Prust
7. Konopka
8. Bissonette
9. Gillies
10. Carkner

 

[alx83*]

Any list without George Parros is a joke. I really wish our fourth line played more, you'd actually see him put up points.

 

[straka91*]

^^Agreed^^

Come on, Where is DJ King.
He is definitely in the top 3 best fighters in the league. S. Mac is the only one that could be argued to be a better fighter.

Don't believe me. Youtube him.

He had an off year imo. Part of it was because fatso refused to dress him and the other part is the fights he had this season were not that impressive. Hope he has a rebound year next season.

As for not putting Lucic on my list. I consider him more of a Power Foward than an enforcer type.

 

[straka91*]

My revised enforcing list.

1.Godard
2.Gillies
3.Thornton
4.Boll
5.Parros
6.Boulton-so underrated
7.Big Mac
8.Bam Bam
9.Hordicuck
10.Shelley-he tries lol

HM: Engelland/Erskine(HW status is ?), Scott, Barch, Biznasty, and Westgarth

Not included due to injuries: Orr, Carkner, Late Boogaard, Koci, King(lack of playing time), and Ivanans

Based it mostly on enforcing and not just fighting skill or their wins/losses. Only included HW's so thats why you dont see Prust or Konopka types in my list.

 

[Eaglepride*]

whats so cool about Smac is his "hulking it up" the guy is a beast unleashed but when hes pissed hes really hammering like a machine.

 

[Central Scrutinizer]

Thornton

 

[ajost]

where is david clarkson? hes definetly one of them and also can score goals

 

[Stecz]

where is david clarkson? hes definetly one of them and also can score goals

David Clarkson an enforcer? Pest, yes, enforcer, not a chance.

 

[rt]

Trevor Gillies would top my list.

 

[Illinihockey]

John Scott can't even get guys in the West to fight him most of the time.

 

[Aurel Joliat]

1. Steve MacIntyre
2. Trevor Gillies
3. Colton Orr
4. John Scott
5. Deryk Engellend
6. Matt Carkner
7. Eric Boulton
8. Paul Bissonette
9. George Parros
10. Cam Janssen

 

[Duke749]

I don't know if Eric Boulton is a top 10 ENFORCER in the league. Top 10 fighter? Obviously. But I don't know if he's mean enough.

 

[alby05]

I'm not sure if MacIntyre took his number but Theo Peckham did. He was ready to chase Avery down the hall way to get a piece of him. I'm sure they will be reintroduced the next time the Oilers and Rangers meet. He said after the game that he was disappointed they don't play the Rangers again this season.

Whether it be a hit or a fight...I'm sure Peckham will find a way to get a piece of Avery.

Where's the Horton - Peckham fight? Didn't make the clip?

 

[Nikita Filatov]

My revised enforcing list.

1.Godard
2.Gillies
3.Thornton
4.Boll
5.Parros
6.Boulton-so underrated
7.Big Mac
8.Bam Bam
9.Hordicuck
10.Shelley-he tries lol

HM: Engelland/Erskine(HW status is ?), Scott, Barch, Biznasty, and Westgarth

Not included due to injuries: Orr, Carkner, Late Boogaard, Koci, King(lack of playing time), and Ivanans

Based it mostly on enforcing and not just fighting skill or their wins/losses. Only included HW's so thats why you dont see Prust or Konopka types in my list.

Any list that includes Boll is wrong. Sure the guy fights, but I don't think he's ever enforced anything on anyone.

 

[JerseyGuy276]

David Clarkson an enforcer? Pest, yes, enforcer, not a chance.

What? Pests don't fight. Clarkson fights.

 

[Eaglepride*]

What? Pests don't fight. Clarkson fights.

this is about top 10 enforcers I'm not sure if I would rank him in the top 20 too. Avery is an agitator "pest" and does fight too but that doesn't make him an enforcer.

 

[CHGoalie27]

LOL @ anyone who not only doesn't put MacIntyre as top 3, but doesn't mention him at all.

No, not LOL...facepalm.

 

[Flash Walken]

#1 with a Bullet, Eric Godard

 

[y2kcanucks]

Rick Rypien. The best pound for pound fighter in the NHL.