I also think this playoff format sucks, but have to believe that one of Washington/Columbus/Philadelphia regresses a little over the course of the season. All three are playing at paces that would win a presidents trophy some years.
CLB is clearly playing much better than last year, but not Philly or WSH.
Philly is currently playing at a 103 point pace for the season, and they ended up last year with 96. Overall, the really aren't playing at a level much higher than last year. And they really stunk early last season and really turned it around the 2nd half.
WSH is playing at a 112 point pace this year, and they ended up last year with 120. They are actually on a worse pace than last season.
CLB for sure. They are on a 120 point pace and last year had 76 points. That said, in order for them to drop to 93 points (a bit arbitrary, but 94 is a typical wild card cut point), they'd have to play at an 80 point pace the rest of the way. I agree they may regress, but unless injuries hit, I can't see them regressing to basically last year's level of play for the remainder of the season. Their underlying metrics are pretty decent as well.
- They are +31 in GF vs. GA which is 2nd in the entire NHL.
- Their possession stats are in the top half of the NHL as well (not great, but not terrible #13).
- They are 3rd best in the NHL for SV%
- They are #1 in the NHL for PP%.
- They are middle of the NHL (17th) for PK%
If they have major injuries, particularly to their goalie, then yes, they could fall drastically. I do expect them to fall back some, but would be surprised if they miss the playoffs (barring big injuries).