Price had a good year, but let's be serious. If he was a bad coach he'd have missed the playoffs, not gotten the team to the semi finals and beating out a favored Bruins team.
You're letting you own interpretation cloud your judgment. Most people who know the game seem to think MT is good at putting guys in situations to succeed. Not only do you exaggerate his "shortcomings" but you create some that don't exist.
Ridiculous.
Yup, every time Tinordi and Beaulieu were in the line-up with Bouillon, they had to play their off-side. Great coaching and putting your rookies up for success, especially in Beaulieu's case, to put him on his off side, as a rookie, in the play-offs, because you can't rely on your "stout veteran" to play on his off side.
Early PP against the Rangers and instead of understanding the situation, taking the time-out and getting his top PP unit back on the ice. He went with an under performing powerplay unit that did nothing all game. They stayed out for a 1:30 without producing a shot, we didn't score on the PP and later lost the game.
Consistently he puts his worst defensive pair out with his fourth line. Briere and Bouillon fumbling around uselessly in their defensive zone while the Rangers produced the only goal in game 6. Another example of understanding the situation and putting out players in a situation to succeed.
All series long against the Rangers we were stuck in our zone, icing the puck, yet at no point did he teach a break out involving short passes and creating speed through the neutral zone. Stuck to icing and turning the puck over, many goals against caused by the wingers being at the attacking blueline while our D turned the puck over.
Galchenyuk and Eller notably missing from the powerplay all season and most of the series. Didn't matter that Eller was our most productive center in the play-offs. The minutes had to go to Davey. Always Davey. Didn't matter DD was barely productive in any situation during the play-offs. He played his favorites and died with them.
What else do we need to know about this expert tactician? Oh, that we watched both our D chase the puck behind the net constantly. Always bleeding goals and glorious scoring chances because a peewee level adjustment was never taught or implemented into our gameplan. Why were we always chasing the puck behind our net, with both D men and our center none the less? God knows. You can say players failed to execute. Maybe one game or two. But every game? Nope, thats on the coaches to identify the problem and rectify it.
How often did we lament his time out use? He never ever had the pulse of the game. Many situations where we needed a time out to calm down, to get the players back on the ice that we need, but he stuffed them in his back pocket and had them rusting in those pockets by the end of the game.
Line up decisions were always a problem. Murray against the Bruins was one example of that. Every one knew that decision would cost us and it did. We were lucky that the Bruins kept giving us motivation to beat them or we may not have gotten out of that series alive. Prust playing at all was always mind boggling. The guy was clearly broken and never really contributed anything to the team except receiving a suspension.
How about the development of Galchenyuk? Kid with a boat load of talent never seeing the powerplay time he deserved. Still stuck on the wing despite every one knowing he has more talent and wherewithal on the ice than Desharnais. Had one game at center and it was against the incredibly deep St. Louis Blues team. Baptism by fire and no chance at redemption. When players get waived out of the circle, he doesn't even come in on the draw. Why would we not use that opportunity to give him more reps on face-offs at the NHL level to help with the adjustment later? No matter what your thoughts are on development and "Cases" to the contrary, you can't learn Center at the NHL level by being on the wing. The responsibilities are different, defensively, offensively, positioning wise and virtue of carrying the puck as well. Especially when we are primarily a dump and chase team.
These are a selected few of the many, many problems with Therrien. Let's not herald him as some amazing coach because Price had an incredible year. Bishop was injured in round 1 and the Bruins lost their minds and gave us ammunition to beat them. Hes still the same moron who gets out coached and got embarrassed by the Senators last year. The same Senators team that failed to even threaten for the play-offs this year.