I see "Fan" is the first "echoing the philosophy" as I said would happen in my post. It is a philosophy I don't agree with and that's all right.
Never said a thing about a particular season. I spoke to a philosophy Benning has about getting his shiny new toys onto the big club as fast as possible. I don't believe it is a wise pattern to follow and neither do most successful NHL franchises. They start all but the blue chip, can't miss guys in the A until they develop their game to the point they are just too good for the AHL. Some even give those blue chippers a short stint first just to get their pro feet wet.
Last season Boeser was an example of the blue chip can't miss. No problemo.
In the past Virtanen, McCann, Hutton, and Stecher were not blue chip can't miss players who should have started in the AHL.
Now:
McCann plays for another franchise that immediately sent him to the minors after a quick look and publicly stated he was not ready for the NHL. He is just now starting to show his talent level. There also hasn't been any problems with his "attitude".
Jake played a full season in the NHL and showed to all but the blind believers that he wasn't ready. Then he proved it with a full season in the AHL where he still struggled. Now the hype is he will become a solid 3rd liner. Most franchises hope their #6OA becomes much more than a solid 3rd liner.
Many posters hailed Hutton as a budding star and now the clamor is to dump him at the draft for a 3rd round pick while "he still has some value".
Stecher is in much the same boat.
Both D-men are playing lesser roles on a team with a crap defense to begin with and not putting up any offense and getting beat in their own end on a nightly basis. They would not be in the top six on most NHL teams.
This throw the kid to the wolves and let him learn by the seat of his pants is the same idea as throwing the child out of the boat and saying sink or swim. Most non-swimmers have to be rescued before they drown. Horvat swam. Not so much with the others. I do not agree with this style of player development. Neither does Shanahan nor Yzerman who are proving very successful in developing kids. The NHL is not a development league. It's why the AHL exists. Benning uses his AHL affiliate to stash call-ups where they can play until needed and to hope against hope that his unsigned acquisitions might blossom.
My contention this season is that Dahlen, Gaudette, Lind, Gadjovich, Palmu, and even Juloevi should open the 2018-19 hockey season in the AHL. Vancouver isn't going anywhere. They need a couple more top picks. Bite the bullet and play the roster players they already have, sprinkle in the number of missing spots from the number of players we all know will be available at cut- down time and sign them to 1-yr contracts. There wouldn't have to be many as the Canucks already have almost enough guys if they were just to sign their RFA/UFAs: Virtanen, Granlund, Baertschi, Stecher, Pouliot, Dowd, and Archibald. If they are not happy with all of them replace those with the available free agents I just referred to. You could actually add Demko to the group of kids you assign to the farm. Marky and Nilsson are still under contract.
During the year any Comet who eats up the AHL gets promoted, but papered to Utica for the playoffs. This is after the Canucks are done with their playoff run. Check out who Toronto sent back. One of them leads the Marlies in playoff scoring.
Then next season the 1-yr guys expire. The kids on the farm have built a rapport with one another, maybe had some success (can't see why they wouldn't), and can now move onto the big club with a sense of confidence developed in playing in all the key situations and learned the pro game and the Travis's system. It's also possible some have played quite a few games in Vancouver due to injuries or TDL trades. They go back for the AHL playoffs and see what they can accomplish with what they started. It's certainly worked for Toronto as just one example and Tampa Bay's lineup was peppered with guys groomed on the farm in Syracuse is another.
Pettersson appears to be one of those blue chip can't miss types, but his physical development may be the determining factor here. What a shame it would be to lose this rising star to an injury that changes his whole future because somebody just couldn't wait long enough for him to be ready because of the tickets he will sell.
I know I'm just a dumb AHL fan who knows nothing about the purpose of a farm team and its relationship with the parent club. I'm just selfish and want these good players to play in Utica. It can't have any semblance of believing that player development is the most important purpose of the farm, but you have to have players there that can develop into NHL players. When you have players to develop, I believe you you do just that - develop them.
Thinking Chatfield, Carcone, Molino, D'Aoust, and MacEwen are the type of players you develop into NHL players down on the farm is absurd. Brisebois was the only Vancouver player that fits the role of a budding possible NHL player and he is as raw as they come. You might get a couple of these guys every year out of the entire AHL who become regular NHL players. That's why you take a chance on them, but when they don't make it it's not because the coach there doesn't know how to develop players. They were not good enough in the first place and everyone knew it , but hoped against hope they would turn out to be one of those found diamonds. They also are not the players you build an AHL roster around.
At the moment I would predict that D'Aoust and Molino are career fringe AHl players at best and Molino may be nothing more than ECHL material. Carcone and Chatfield are guys who can make a career in the AHL and maybe earn a call-up or two. MacEwen could become a bottom line NHLer, but those types are a dime a dozen available every year at NHL cut-down time and wander around the league and bounce up and down with each team's minor affiliate until they become only AHL players once again and then head to Europe and excel in those European leagues that so many hockey fans here hold in such high regards in comparison to the AHL where more than 87% of all NHL players have played some part of their hockey careers.
I hope to see every player in a Comets uniform wearing an Orca jersey. I also realize that won't come close to happening. Reality always brings dreams to a crashing halt.