qc
Registered User
- Aug 23, 2011
- 12,761
- 11
Seguin is a better partier then Eriksson AIAEC
Ya plus Loui is clearly in the process of a dive. So soft.
Last edited:
Seguin is a better partier then Eriksson AIAEC
Currently lirling. Well done.
Eriksson has played well below his normal level this season. I don't know how that's even debatable. Seguin was moved because the team no longer felt he was going to continue to develop here. Nothing more needs to be said as to why the trade happened, IMO.
What is still debatable is whether they got enough in return for him, and if the skill set Eriksson brings is too similar to a number of players they already had on the roster. That's the one thing people don't want to talk about. How many good but not great, two way players does one team really need? Can a team with no dynamic scorers actually succeed? If they had an elite offensive player last year in the finals, would that have made a difference? Seems to me, that having to rely on the defense to score goals finally caught up to them, right when it mattered most. Watching them this year, it appears they're right back doing it again.
Agreed on both counts. Part of me wouldn't mind seeing Marchand down on the 3rd line for a bit and putting Soderberg with Eriksson, see if the 2 countrymen can get a bit of chemistry going together. That line would pretty much instantly be the highest hockey-IQ line in the league.
I love his game. Strong and smart with the puck. Both he and Soderberg will be a huge source of stability and strength that the second and third lines have been lacking for, just about, ever.
Some very good points LSC...
The "scoring by committee" worked pretty well on '11 and we're gonna have to hope it works again, because it doesn't appear that Chia, Cam & Claude (C3) will change what has been working for them.
It did work in 11, and that may be part of the reluctance to have a guy like that (IE a one dimensional elite offensive type of player) here, whether it's a positive or negative. Was the 11 win a fluke, or is the FO on to something here? You can point to the return to the finals last years as proof they're on to something, but they came up short against a team that had a mix of good two way players and elite scoring. To me, that means the opposite can be argued, if you chose to do so.
Either way, is the team as it's constituted today better suited to win it all? I personally don't know. I think there are a lot of big questions about the makeup of the team and of the new guys on the roster this year. If they had rolled into this season with the same guys, I think I'd feel better because I had a track record to refer back to. With Loui, Smith, Iginla, Soda, and the newly injected youth on the back end, it's hard to gauge.
Ya plus Loui is clearly in the process of a dive. So soft.
Lol... i wonder if that picture you had quoted captured the highlight of Tyler's playoff performance last year
The biggest question mark for me is whether Iginla can replicate Horton's contributions, I love the way he is playing now but I loved what Horton brought in the playoffs. I am not too concerned about Loui as long as Bergeron and Marchand are on their games and surely Soda is going to bring more to the table than Peverley did.
Ya plus Loui is clearly in the process of a dive. So soft.
"I want to create this Eriksson thread and not have anyone talk about Seguin in it so I'm going to put 'official Seguin thread' in the title... and then complain if anyone mentions Seguin in it"
Yep. You just don't know. Horton come playoffs was a beast. Hard to expect that from anyone that replaces him. Especially a 35 year old guy on the backside of his career. In terms of the other stuff, you hope and expect, but again, you don't know.
Iginla should be able to replicate Horton and Nate did zip on the Chicago series- as for Eriksson against Seguin, that 1 goal in 24 games might be tough. As long as Loui doesn't pull a Seguin-like matador job in game 6 on that PP that led to a Hawks shortie and life I'm fine with 1 goal in two dozen games. I don't expect the Calgary Tomato Cans on the playoff schedule.
Yep. You just don't know. Horton come playoffs was a beast. Hard to expect that from anyone that replaces him. Especially a 35 year old guy on the backside of his career. In terms of the other stuff, you hope and expect, but again, you don't know.
Seguin is a better partier then Eriksson AIAEC
Who the hell does Loui Eriksson think he is? I mean it looks like a grown man - and an NHL player to boot - is scoring goals against a bunch of kids. Trade the bum!
I think there is every reason for optimism. Lucic looks like a man possessed playing opposite Iggy... they dominate puck possession as well as any line in the league.
At this point, the KIL line is looking superior (as a unit) than the LKH line was last year... and every bit as good as when LKH was at its peak. I really do think part of why Horton was so effective in the playoffs is because of the number of regular season games that he appeared to have "taken off"... Horty mailed it in for some regular season games.
That's just a theory of why he seemed so much more effective in the playoffs. I guess the same could be said for his linemates, but to a lesser extent IMO. Horton coasted for long stretches during regular season games.
Iggy is visibly putting in so much effort, which is great (and is yielding results), but i DO also wonder if he may be gassed come playoff time. Let's hope he is doing everything he can to stay well-conditioned.
After all, Big Z is carrying around a much bigger body, plays more minutes, and is even older than Iggy is. But come playoff time he has plenty in the tank, you can't just go by age... although age is always a factor.
Ultimately i think Iggy can smell a deep Cup run on this quality B's squad and having been stuck in Calgary all those years, this is the kind of opportunity he has waited for his ENTIRE CAREER... he is now within reach of a possible Stanley Cup (the ultimate goal). That will keep him motivated and focused IMO, or at least i hope.
Either way, is the team as it's constituted today better suited to win it all? I personally don't know. I think there are a lot of big questions about the makeup of the team and of the new guys on the roster this year. If they had rolled into this season with the same guys, I think I'd feel better because I had a track record to refer back to. With Loui, Smith, Iginla, Soda, and the newly injected youth on the back end, it's hard to gauge.
Oh no. My life is over. How will I ever find the will to go on if you don't want to discuss things with me...
For the record, my general rule of thumb is that if I'm arguing on the same side of a point as you, I must be either drunk, or have fallen and hit my head.
Eriksson has played well below his normal level this season. I don't know how that's even debatable. Seguin was moved because the team no longer felt he was going to continue to develop here. Nothing more needs to be said as to why the trade happened, IMO.
What is still debatable is whether they got enough in return for him, and if the skill set Eriksson brings is too similar to a number of players they already had on the roster. That's the one thing people don't want to talk about. How many good but not great, two way players does one team really need? Can a team with no dynamic scorers actually succeed? If they had an elite offensive player last year in the finals, would that have made a difference? Seems to me, that having to rely on the defense to score goals finally caught up to them, right when it mattered most. Watching them this year, it appears they're right back doing it again.
You're absolutely correct. The team is in a great spot, and has a solid core of key players. Lots to be excited about right now. How it all shakes out will be interesting to watch. If they show a continued lack of scoring, does PC go out and get someone at the deadline? Do they stand pat and coast through the regular season and then flip the switch in the playoffs? Can Iginla keep up his pace through the full year and through the playoffs? Can PB, BM, and LE get it together and gel? There have been a lot of growing pains early, and they're still in great position. If they figure it all out, they could be a very scary team to play come playoffs.
You're absolutely correct. The team is in a great spot, and has a solid core of key players. Lots to be excited about right now. How it all shakes out will be interesting to watch. If they show a continued lack of scoring, does PC go out and get someone at the deadline? Do they stand pat and coast through the regular season and then flip the switch in the playoffs? Can Iginla keep up his pace through the full year and through the playoffs? Can PB, BM, and LE get it together and gel? There have been a lot of growing pains early, and they're still in great position. If they figure it all out, they could be a very scary team to play come playoffs.