The LWMD - Discussion Thread Part Greg Adams

[Tryamkin]

yeah and I'll vote for whichever

I think you should reveal the 3 teams and everyone should vote on who they think should make it

 

[VanillaCoke]

But C still has to vote and can vote for A or B

I think if you didn't vote, tough noogies. That's on you for not voting

These statements are contradictory.

 

[VanillaCoke]

I think you should reveal the 3 teams and everyone should vote on who they think should make it

Were already voting on the vote.....


(not trying to single you out)

 

[Tryamkin]

Were already voting on the vote.....


(not trying to single you out)

I'm saying he should let everyone know the team's names (ie: Chicago, Anahiem, Winnipeg) and let everyone vote on who should go on based on best team. Not based on who voted for or on what

 

[Tryamkin]

These statements are contradictory.

My point is that C could vote for team A or B without knowing it. It could backfire in C's face either way

 

[VanillaCoke]

I'm saying he should let everyone know the team's names (ie: Chicago, Anahiem, Winnipeg) and let everyone vote on who should go on based on best team. Not based on who voted for or on what

We did that with our initial votes. Seems rather redundant to do it again.
Resolving a tie is the obstacle and A,B,C keeps it impartial.


Edit. Anyway I'll wait and see what sedinary thinks.

 

[Captain Bowie]

Youve got bam19 twice yo

Oopsie-daisy.

 

[DanCloutiers5hole]

Personally i think you should remove personal votes then count remaining votes. If still tied most 1st place votes , if still tied most 2nd etc etc

 

[nameless1]

Personally i think you should remove personal votes then count remaining votes. If still tied most 1st place votes , if still tied most 2nd etc etc

I agree with this.
It will probably make it easier too.

 

[StrictlyCommercial]

Radim is right, my vote would be for C if they have 11 points without even voting for themselves.

 

[Captain Bowie]

Looks like Team C is the choice. By several accounts they come out on top (taking away personal votes, only one to get a first vote from another manager, ect..)

So Team C it is. I will post the results shortly.

 

[Ainec]

I think for polling it would be best to go by seed #s in title and team names within

Not going to get a lot of clicks with Arizona vs Dallas for example compared to Toronto vs Montreal

 

[Vankiller Whale]

I think for polling it would be best to go by seed #s in title and team names within

Not going to get a lot of clicks with Arizona vs Dallas for example compared to Toronto vs Montreal

I think we're avoiding team names altogether so that people aren't biased for/against a team based on that

 

[Bam19]

I think we're avoiding team names altogether so that people aren't biased for/against a team based on that

I thought we were doing this as well

 

[Captain Bowie]

Results are posted: http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showthread.php?t=1978641