The OP is spot on, and more people need to say it.
This fan base and franchise is nothing but a leg for the league to stand on, and a dog to kick when necessary. I'm sick of it as well.
Mapes hit the nail on the head.
The Maple Leafs ownership and management is to blame for this mess. Think about it. NonisMustGo was talking about the 1993 playoffs with having players with heart and skill. Those 1990's teams happened because Steve Stavro let hockey personnel make the decisions. Someone like Cliff Fletcher was able to make many deals without major interference from ownership.
This is why Detroit did well with Mike Ilitch letting Ken Holland make the decision on deals, and why Chicago did well after Bill Wirtz passed away and his son Rocky took over letting Dale Tallon/Stan Bowman make decisions on hockey operations.
What have the Leafs ownership done over the last twenty years? Always having General Managers told to make the team competitive instantly each year throwing away first and second round draft picks for quick fixes. In the salary cap era this is a recipe for disaster, and why the Leafs are in this situation.
John Ferguson Jr. trades Rask for Raycroft to make a quick fix, then you have the first round pick traded for Vesa Toskala. Two first round picks and a second for Phil Kessel? I mean really, did Brian Burke not see who the goaltender was on the team and the other players at the time the trade was made? A second round pick for a few months of Dave Bolland? See the pattern and the problem here?
It has been obvious all along the mandate to Ferguson, Burke, and Nonis has been to make the team competitive right away by trading away the future. If the team has no future then of course it will be spinning its wheels for decades because there is no support in the from the draft to put the salt on the road to make the vehicle (team) move forward.
The League is not responsible to fix the lottery to give an incompetent ownership group a coveted first overall player for their decade of mismanagement. Rogers made the deal hoping the sacred cash cow can make them billions of dollars without having to do anything.
They are now learning that fans have a breaking point and will have to revise their strategy to actually do what all the other 29 NHL teams have been doing in the salary cap era for the most part and start drafting their future stars along with their support players.
McDavid alone will not help the Leafs, they will need those second round drafted players like Bergeron, Saad, etc. to help the roster fill out for contention. It will take smart drafting and developing to get this team out of this mess.
What proof is there that they are trying to rebuild the team? No fan here has shown any. They kept their main core.... Bozak got a hat trick and the Leafs win a game - which hurt their chances of getting a better (well, worse in the standings) shot at the top draft pick. Yes, maybe they will get a Marner or Strome which is still good but the #1 overall lets them choose either of those plus McDavid.
There was all this talk of tanking but I don't see it. I see it with Buffalo. Phoenix was accused of it, too. Edmonton made trades but they're already lousy. The Leafs kept most of their core compared to these teams. They were beating teams like Tampa and others - would that happen if they cleaned house? Probably not.
Why would you keep a GM on this long if you are planning to use new personnel to draft/trade/build etc.? Imho, Shanahan is just a figurehead for the PR dept. and for the fans/media to concentrate on. He's mostly invisible and the moves have been minor for the most part.
The Leafs still have a horrible record/rep for developing their talent. The last poll had the Leafs as one of the bottom (i.e. least preferred) teams to be traded to. Few players want to play for this franchise. They're inept although they're known to overpay and hand out nice no-trade/movement clauses but it's not enough to convince players to be interested in playing there. The media is only bad when they are not winning. But, with the media so connected to Sportsnet and other Rogers-companies, it's not going to be that bad. Leafs columnists still want access so they'll sugarcoat their criticism. The Leafs ownership know they can rely on the fans and the revenue/profits are highest of all the teams. There's no incentive to change or improve anything.
Although I agree, it saddens me that so many people poor their lives into a team that is founded on a business. This is sport. What happens when the leafs win the cup?
I have been a long time fan and I have finally come to my wits end. Several months ago I stopped watching this team altogether. It wasn't necessarily this unlikable roster, but more to do with a decade of failure and the growing resentment I have had not only for management, but of the NHL as a whole. .
I think the likeability factor or lack there of this roster is an issue plaguing this team, affecting the ratings and playing a factor in how the media reports on them.
I think a hard working team that give 110% effort every night even when they lose is still a team fans enjoy supporting through think and thin. This team has players giving 10% even to the point their own coach is calling it the don't-give-a-crap meter being at an all time low.
The 1980's teams were not very good but Wendel Clark hitting, fighting, scoring and doing everything in his power to win. I think Shanny is going to bring in new players with a strong compete meter and it will rub off on the other players to increase their own intensity.
I agree. That just shows fans like 'Cy Nick' just don't get it. They don't need to win. They make a profit that is highest in the League, regardless of how they do on the ice.The fans had to stop watching and paying. The team was used to support non viable teams while paying top $$ to watch a gutted team.Over the years we have simply thrown away S.Niedermayer,Courtnall,Luongo,Rask,Steen,Couture,Seguin,Hamilton but the fans kept paying.As long as Toronto made $$ they were content to be the laughing stock of the league.And now after what, 47 years ? It is finally ending and a new era is beginning, no Leaf fans to support the non viable teams. They may have lost fans for years and that wont be good for the NHL.
Do you ever think some of it was intentional instead of just sheer stupidity?
I have been a long time fan and I have finally come to my wits end. Several months ago I stopped watching this team altogether. It wasn't necessarily this unlikable roster, but more to do with a decade of failure and the growing resentment I have had not only for management, but of the NHL as a whole.
I am 31 years old, I have watched this team since I was 5. I remember immediately the terrible goaltending tandem of Peter Ing and Allen Bester. I remember the hype behind some obscure Russian prospect whose calling card came when he was shipped to Calgary in part of the Gilmour trade. I remember my father telling me what the Leafs meant to him, even as a teenager who barely spoke English. In that 1993 series against Detroit, it was my dad who told me to hold out hope late in the 3rd period, and sure enough it was the most satisfying victory I have ever experienced as a Leaf fan.
In the last 30 years this franchise has had some good to great players. Never a team talented enough to go all the way. Pat Quinn, God bless his soul, got more out of a roster than any other coach we had in the past. Who could have imagined a team with a defense tandem of Lumme and Berg could make it to the Conference Final? It wasn't necessarily the quality of the roster, but the team cohesion and great goaltending that led to some near successes.
The last decade has been a complete embarrassment for this organization. Sadly, they were not punished financially until late this season. The value of the Leafs has grown significantly since the lock-out of 2004-2005. In that time-frame we, the Leaf fan base, have had to witness franchises win Cups with superstar players we could only dream of having. After the more recent lock-out I have started paying attention to how the league works, and after reading more about revenue sharing Leaf fans should be outraged. The blatant hypocrisy displayed by the owners and the NHL is a slap in the face, and furthermore, the players are becoming entitled. I do not blame the players, they need to benefit from their dealings with the owners, after all, they are ultimately the product and any one of us would take a sweetheart deal; however, it just isn't tasteful anymore.
As teams like Tampa transitioned from Lecavalier, Richards, and St. Louis to Hedman and Stamkos, I have watched the Leafs ice teams that included the likes of John Pohl, Andy Wozniewski, JS Aubin, Bates Battaglia, Andrew Raycroft, Vesa Toskala, Jason Blake, and who knows how many other plugs have had the honour of skating on the ACC ice surface. This current crop of players is just a collection of misfits and brats. Besides a handful of players, the management needs to totally revamp their roster. Hopefully, the next group of players appreciate where they play and leave their blood, sweat and tears on the ice. This city deserves it.
My ultimate point is, for too long Leaf fans have been propping up the NHL and its terrible business decisions. Canadian fans as a whole deserve better. Many of these players are born and raised in our cities and are educated in our schools, while playing in rinks paid for by tax payer money. Admiring them from a far while watching our own wretched team has become too taxing. If on draft day, Rogers is not 'rewarded' for acquiring the television rights for a bush league professional sports league while also owning one of the biggest hockey franchises in Canada I am officially out. The mismanagement of this league borders on asinine.
I can understand the frustration from the fans, I'm frustrated too. But I don't want to get any handouts from the NHL, I want US to win, with good management, good coaching, good players. I'm now sensing that if we do win, everyone is going to at the lottery is rigged, and I honestly hope that's not the case. I don't want McDavid or wins to come through cheating, because then it's not really a win. My life doesn't depend on a Leaf win, so if they win I want it to be earned. Them winning or losing doesn't impact me or my ego in anyways. I just love the game and I love Toronto.
I also don't understand why people complain about Toronto supporting the weaker teams in the league. So what, it's not your money. If it makes the league more competitive and gets more people watching hockey, I'm all for it. I know Canadians are the country that are most associated with hockey, but I definitely don't want it to be like that forever, I want it to get as big as basketball in the US. It's just better entertainment for everyone, and the more people that can enjoy it, the better cause it is seriously the best sport in the world.
I also don't think that MLSE doesn't care about the fans and only cares about profits. Any company would rather have goodwill from their customers than just making money. They've made mistakes, but so have the fans. I don't think it serves anyone to linger in the past, let's just focus on doing things the right way, and hopefully MLSE follows suit.
And the ripples will be felt around the NHL they just don't see it yet.A trend which took 4 decades to build, won't be turned around so easily.The Leaf fans have been abused and used by the NHL for too long, it is now payback time.I think I watched one full game all year and wont be watching the playoffs, why bother? Cdn teams aren't allowed to win anyway. Once the fans turn their backs on the Leafs, non viable American teams will fall one by one even if they are hand gifted McDavid.
wow. idk what to say about this post but:
1) idc how we win, as long as we win
2) didn't realize everyone in pittsburgh hates that they won the lottery to get crosby, they probably all hate hockey knowing that they were gift wrapped a winner
3) MLSE cares more about making a profit than it does about fans, they tried to make it seem like they were doing the fans a favour by not raising the ticket prices... like comon
4) The fans pay for the tickets, they pay for the television stations to watch the games, ultimatley its our dollars that are going towards helping teams like Arizona and Florida.
i know what your saying, but i 100% disagree
What does the league have to do with the awful management of this team for the past 3 decades?
They arent here to babysit us. When we win a Cup I dont want it to be because the league "rewarded" us with unfair advantages. I want it to be because we were the best through proper development, talent, and management.
This leauge is far from mismanaged; its stronger then ever. Whats mismanaged is the Leafs. Thats not Bettman's fault. Indeed interference on his part in giving us a "reward" would be more bush league then anything in your post.
The league owes us nothing.Only our ownership and management is to blame.I feel the OP's pain and agree with him 100% except expecting the league to reward us for something we don't deserve.so because the teams been run like crap the league owes us a generational talent ?
how about we suck it up for a few years and draft and develop like the other successful teams and stop believing their some miraculous short cut to building a legit contender
had Burke not decided to do a quickie retool we'd be on the upswing right now and not staring at gutting the team and doing a proper rebuild that should have been started years ago