Value of: Signed Taylor Hall on July 1st (trade)

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

It is such a waste of time to discuss Hall's unwillingness to sign an extension, before he's even eligible to sign said extension.

Can't we save this conversation until after he can sign in July 2019?

 

[Darkauron]

How about we not speculate on something we know knowing about about yet.

 

[Cobra Commander]

Those are all projections - Hall is a proven MVP who would be signed long term

It wouldnt even come close

Suzuki would be the 3rd best piece going the other way

Those 3 guys + 1st + spare parts is the most I would give up. We can’t afford to give you roster players. Especially not the ones you want.

 

[Hostile Offer]

Suzuki
Brook
Poehling

For:

Hall

Habs aren't in the position to make a trade like that.

 

[Hischier and Hughes]

It is such a waste of time to discuss Hall's unwillingness to sign an extension, before he's even eligible to sign said extension.

Can't we save this conversation until after he can sign in July 2019?

How about we not speculate on something we know knowing about about yet.

at what age did your imaginations die?

Holy shit , idt ive seen people struggle with the word hypothetical as much as i have in the first hour of this thread...

 

[Cobra Commander]

This is ****ing terrible

I added a 1st round pick.

Your getting 2 blue chip prospects plus a very good prospect in Poehling who is at the very least going to be a 3rd line center for you.

If you are rebuilding, the value is definitely there.

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

We ca


Those 3 guys + 1st + spare parts is the most I would give up. I can’t afford to give you roster players. Especially not the ones you want.

Then we aren't prepared to give you the league MVP.

Your offer is garbage.

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

at what age did your imaginations die?

Holy **** , idt ive seen people struggle with the word hypothetical as much as i have in the first hour of this thread...

A half-scroll down the page is a thread with a title highlighting Hall's benching and New Jersey potentially needing a shake-up.

You seriously you'd field fair, thoughtful offers in this thread?

 

[JCRO]

Probably going to catch **** for this. No, definitely will.

But I'd absolutely look at a trade revolving around Hall for Jake DeBrusk +.

Both contracts expire after next season.

Hall is obviously due for a raise so it would take Sweeney some maneuvering. Especially after next season where Heinen, McAvoy, Carlo, etc. needs raises. Boston also would have to move some cap to make it work with his current cap hit I believe.

NJ gets a really impressive younger wing still on his ELC plus some added parts to that trade. Boston gets a guy for Krejci to drool over and solidify that second line.

(Runs back to his Xbox to continue playing NHL 19).

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

I added a 1st round pick.

Your getting 2 blue chip prospects plus a very good prospect in Poehling who is at the very least going to be a 3rd line center for you.

If you are rebuilding, the value is definitely there.

It appears we have very differing opinions on what "blue chip" means.

 

[Cobra Commander]

Then we aren't prepared to give you the league MVP.


Your offer is garbage.

He’s a great player, but why would we want to trade Drouin that’s on pace for 70 points in a breakout year? And Domi.. he’s our number 1 center, he’s worth more to us than Hall would be..

 

[Cobra Commander]

It appears we have very differing opinions on what "blue chip" means.

Suzuki and Brook are both killing the CHL
Susuki is projected to be a top 6 forward sniper and Brook a top pairing defenseman.

Suzuki is captain of the OHL team

Brook is captain of the WHL team

If that’s not blue chip then what is? Maybe I’m using the term wrong.
They are both VERY good prospects and leaders on their teams, let’s put it that way.

 

[AnInjuredJasonZucker]

Adam Larsson.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Ana: Kessel + Maatta
NJ: Fowler + M. Murray + Ritchie + Ana cap dump
Pitt: Hall (signed long term) + Schneider + Mueller

 

[Hischier and Hughes]

Ana: Kessel + Maatta
NJ: Fowler + M. Murray + Ritchie + Ana cap dump
Pitt: Hall (signed long term) + Schneider + Mueller

I dont think Pitt wants Schneider and idk about value cause thats a lot of moving parts, but Fowler in NJ would be amazing for us

 

[34]

HALL IN MTL MAKE IT HAPPEN

Starts with Kotkaniemi.

 

[Brian McDavid]

Hall is the exact type of player who declines hard in his 30's. It would be smart IMO to move Hall if discussions won't go anywhere instead of overpaying him to stay.

Why? Sure he has a history of playing a bit reckless but I think it's overstated at this point. Hall plays fast... not overly physical.

 

[zharkenby]

at what age did your imaginations die?

Holy **** , idt ive seen people struggle with the word hypothetical as much as i have in the first hour of this thread...

Devil fans are delicate and can’t handle the truth about our team right now. Our boards are unbearable because of all of the delusional fans right now.

 

[JT Kreider]

Just edited the OP, stated its for a signed Hall

My bad for not writing it earlier

There is not going to be any trade with a signed Hall. You are just being unrealistic in an attempt toboost his trade value.

Any team will take Hall unsigned and take their chances on signing him to their own contract. And i don't see what Hall has to gain by agreeing to a sign and trade. He loses all leverage in where he wants to play and is way better off just waiting to go on to the open market as a free agent where he will get more money as well.

It's either the Devils will trade him as a pending 2020 UFA or they keep him.

 

[I Hate Tie DOMI]

Adam Larsson.

Did it really take 38 posts before this was mentioned? C'mon HFBoards smarten up.

 

[Flamesfan62]

PHI: Nolan Patrick + Oskar Lindblom + 2019 1st + Phillipe Myers

NJ: Taylor Hall


Obviously this is something that would never happen. Just thought it would be fun.

Tried to keep the pieces going back to NJ young since it wouldn’t make sense for NJ to take a deal around Voracek + or Simmonds ++ and stuff like that.

That’s a solid offer

 

[Hischier and Hughes]

There is not going to be any trade with a signed Hall. You are just being unrealistic in an attempt toboost his trade value.

Any team will take Hall unsigned and take their chances on signing him to their own contract. And i don't see what Hall has to gain by agreeing to a sign and trade. He loses all leverage in where he wants to play and is way better off just waiting to go on to the open market as a free agent where he will get more money as well.

It's either the Devils will trade him as a pending 2020 UFA or they keep him.

From all of the talk, Hall quite literally just wants to contend.

The man lives in Jersey rn so I doubt hed go back to a wasteland, but most of the contending teams are nice places to live right now (Winnipeg cant really afford him anyway). I think he will go wherever he gets the best chance

 

[Mr Tadakichi]

He's gonna end up in Calgary, is he?

 

[ole ole]

Starts with Kotkaniemi.

Oh look a new Devil fan.Color me surprised

 

[ole ole]

PHI: Nolan Patrick + Oskar Lindblom + 2019 1st + Phillipe Myers

NJ: Taylor Hall


Obviously this is something that would never happen. Just thought it would be fun.

Tried to keep the pieces going back to NJ young since it wouldn’t make sense for NJ to take a deal around Voracek + or Simmonds ++ and stuff like that.

I think NJ accepts this offer.