IMO nobody in Bingo is ready to play at the level of Hemsky & Michalek or they would already be here. Hoffman was there best player all yr & he is now in Ottawa. If they decide to go with youth than IMO there would be no reason to keep Spezza, Anderson, Neil or have re-signed Phillips. They are not going to compete any better next season IMO with younger guys than they have with experienced guys this yr.
The difference is that the older guys have experience, they have been there before & they have contributed before at the NHL & can again given the right circumstances, we've seen it with this team & with some of these players. The young will need a maturing period which could take a few yrs depending on the player but we don't have one outstanding player who could make a big difference at the NHL level next season IMO.
Hemsky & Michalek at the very least along with Spezza give Ottawa a top 6 NHL line & they have been playing well together. Without two of those guys Spezza goes back to sucking & PM goes back to trying to find two players who can play with him. Stone can play with Spezza but is he ready to be a top line guy at the NHL level in his first yr in the NHL? I don't think so, I would rather see him brought along slowly & play on the 3rd line with Hoffman & Zibanejad, they used to be Bingo's best line at one point.