What’s past is past, and there is no sense in living in it. I value my experiences as a kid, and I wouldn’t change them, because they’re part of who I am at this moment. That’s part of what this question is asking, would you change your core makeup, your defining experiences as a Flyers fan for the unknown? I want to see a Cup as bad as anybody, I’d trade quite a bit that’s important to me for it, but in all honesty, no, it isn’t worth that price to me.
There is no wrong answer here, no “you’re less of a fan because you believe x instead of y”. We all want to see this team succeed, and bring a little extra happiness to our own, as well as other fans lives.