From where i sit it looks like some people just want him to play and see what he is. If he fails, he fails. No one thinks he's anything yet, they want to see though with their own eyes and not have dolts like Gord Wilson and Dean Brown's and Bruce Garrioch's biased ass reviews.
On the other side it feels like people like you actively hope he fails as an NHLer just so you can tell the 'haters' I told you so.
I just said I don't hate him at all. It's right there.
If you want my opinion, he's the 2nd best PP QB on the team. He's great at walking the line with the puck and finding shooting lanes.
Good passing. Helpful on breakouts. Good handling and creativity.
But, for a small guy, he's not as fast as you'd hope. He can't get himself out of trouble. Takes a lot of contact due to it.
Looks like he needs more lower body strength. Or at least get lower? Not sure exactly what, but he's light on his feet.
He's not able to win net front battles. He gets boxed out. It's a size thing, but also a strength thing.
Now, does his PP ability outweigh the deficiencies at 5v5 play? That's what he needs to sort out, because right now, it's not enough to keep him in the NHL full time, in the opinion of DJ and Dorion, which sucks, because Del Zotto is atrocious at hockey but he's got a 1 way deal.