Just to clarify and out of curiosity - you now have 2 loge seats and are on the wait list for 2 more seats? Are you looking for 4 seats total, something better than loge, or something cheaper than loge? I'm a little confused.
Short answer is yes, I have Loge seats and still on the wait list for 2 more.
The long answer is, I re-entered the wait list when I got my call for P5 seats (front to back).
I wanted to ensure that I was going to be able to get side by side seats so I started burning the candle at both ends... via the wait list and the relocation request. Obviously the relocation request happened sooner, especially with the addition of Loge seats which caused a lot of movement.
After that, my brother and I did consider not renewing our spot on the wait list, mainly because, we already have (what we consider to be) the best seats in the house with a solid group. But for what it's worth (50$ea./year), it's not a big deal to us to see where it leads. If our number gets called 3-4 years from now (after being on the wait list for 10 years, you never know where we will be. Maybe we will want another 2 seats? Or our group will have disbanded and we'll want to get back in some cheaper seats, who knows what life will be like for us in 10 years? Anyway, it's more of a backup plan than anything at this point. We re-evaluate the pros and cons of renewing our wait list every year and we just "let it ride".
I feel a little less value in the 500$ per seat "Premium" fee attached to P1 and Loge seats than the 100$ wait list fee, however, it has been extremely easy to get tickets to popular events at BMTSP for family and friends.