I'd have been against this hiring before Nicholson and especially Chiarelli came on board. It doesn't bother me now that it appears this IS now Chia's team. Also helps that the team is playing well enough for me to forget the reign of error that the OBC brought. This is a pretty minor position too.
As far as Horcoff goes, I could never endorse that guy in any role in this organization. Not only did the guy mail it in for years while cashing big paycheques, he taught our young kids that losing was okay. The clincher for me was him getting busted for PED's last year and trying to claim ignorance. Michigan State grad and a longtime member of the NHLPA should of known better. I wouldn't want his lack of character anywhere near our prospects.
Horcoff is very smart and a hockey guy through and through, he's an asset in any organization, the Red Wings have traditionally had one of the smartest front offices hired him and I think that speaks volumes. I also know a guy who grew up playing with him and he always spoke very highly of him.
With regards to the PED's he was at the tail end of his career and was trying to re-hab an injury, if I was old and not healing properly and could take something to speed the healing process and then just cut it completely out before I was playing again, honestly I think I'd consider it, if you are emotionally invested in a team and just want to get back to being healthy to help the guys out it's understandable. If it is a PED to give you a competitive advantage for competing against other guys in the season it is something I'd be highly critical of.
Also with respect to our young guys Hall, Ebs, RNH, and Yakupov were all asked which veteran helped them the most when they were starting out, they all said Horcoff. Horcoff also helped out older guys he helped train Penner as he had trouble staying in shape and got him on a diet, we got the best season out of Penner's career in no small part cause of Horcoff, if he didn't have that season we likely wouldn't of got that return out of the Kings that gave us Klefbom.
I also disagree about mailing it in, he wasn't a talented guy he only became the player he was through hard work those types generally can't maintain that level of high end play, based purely on skill set he should of capped out as a 3rd liner, it's only cause of his intense dedication to training and hard work that he was able to elevate himself above that. The only thing I ever expect out of players is effort, if they are giving what they got and it is falling short of what they are getting paid that is on the GM.