Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread | You're My Boy Bouch!

Status
Not open for further replies.

5 Mins 4 Ftg

Life is better with no expectations.
Sponsor
Apr 3, 2016
49,652
83,775
Edmonton
I find it hard to believe it will still be held there at this point given what we're dealing with out here

Hopefully highways reopen and familys are back in the homes and everything begins to calm down, but right now very hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel

Perhaps it will be held in Red Deer this year if things are still as severe as they are right now.
 

tiger_80

Registered User
Apr 11, 2007
9,640
2,567
I would be very surprised if he got an offer sheet to be honest. There would have been little point in doing so since it is pretty obvious it would have been matched. if it was near his value. I also see no evidence that offer sheets are more common than we think.

At the time Leon signed the compensation for a $7.85-9.8M offer would have been 2 first a 2nd and a third. That salary and that compensation level for a player who had a career high of 29 goals and 77 points playing with Connor McDavid would have been a very big risk. At that time only Toews, Kane, Kopitar, Benn and Malkin had AAV's of $9M or more amongst forwards. Only those 5, Corey Perry and Sidney Crosby had AAV's over $8.5M. $10M is even much less likely. That would have been 4 1st's and made Draisaitl third highest paid forward in the league.

As a group NHL GM's are typically quite conservative. But even the aggressive ones don't see the OS route as b few years Kevin at offered to take Burkie to the barn.

NHL GMs operate like an old boys club. The reason we don't hear about offer sheets is because there aren't any. These guys don't want to step on anyone else's toes except in a few rare instances. In many scenarios an offer sheet just makes the life of the team holding the players RFA rights easier because all the negotiating is done for them.

There's been 10 offer sheets made since 2006.
5 of those were from 2006-2008 (the beginning of the cap era).
Only two players changed teams (Penner and Kotkaniemi)

The whole worrying/speculating about offer sheet thing is ridiculous to me.
Except the Testosterone Kev, who not only offersheeted Penner, but also threatened to take Burkie to the barn and do to him god knows what )))
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TopShelfGloveSide

McTonyBrar

Registered User
Apr 2, 2018
18,510
19,398
The degree to which Nurse is overpaid is greatly exaggerated. If he was at $8-8.5M he would be a solid value for what he brings to the table. He makes mistakes but the results when he is on the ice are overwhelmingly positive.

He is still top 30 in points for a defenseman, 7th for goals, 12th in ES points and 3rd in Es goals for defensemen over the last 3 years. He is also 8th in +/- so the idea that he bleeds goals against is way overstated especially given the tough minutes he plays. His contract right now is not the reason the Oilers are up against the cap. The only really bad deal the team has is Campbell at $5M for the way he played last year.
100% agreed
 

duul

Registered User
Jun 21, 2010
10,462
5,083
The only players who come here 'on a discount' are mercenary types who are here to ride shotgun with McDavid, earn a contract, and then try to leave.


'
The sense is that Barrie is going to test the free-agent market. He's earned that right and given everything that Ken Holland and the Oilers are going to have to go through with hefty negotiations with Larsson, Nugent-Hopkins, Darnell Nurse, and others, you need to be able to compare apples to apples.

Tyson Barrie would very much like to stay in Edmonton but he also wants some stability. We're talking about a five- or six-year term, so most likely, he goes to the open market to see what the bigger picture looks like as well.


'


'
The Edmonton Oilers have granted Evander Kane permission to speak with other teams before the NHL’s free agency period opens and Colorado’s Nicolas Aube-Kubel went from celebrating with the Stanley Cup on Saturday to not receiving a qualifying offer from the Avalanche on Monday.

70c8fc80

In a text to The Associated Press, Kane’s agent, Daniel Milstein, wrote he’s opening talks with other teams while also continuing discussions with the Oilers with his client eligible to become an unrestricted free agent on Wednesday.


'

The only player in my memory who took a cut to play here is Nuge. This is like the people talking about how Brown signed here for ONLY 775k and what a great guy he is, wanting to come here and win a Cup. No, we are paying him 4 million and no other team in the league was ever going to give him that much.

Coincidentally with the two links I posted, neither of those guys chose to play here on a discount to try and win a championship. They both signed here due to a lack of options with the cap not rising in COVID times. They signed here because they had their contracts terminated or they thought an opportunity would arise where they could play here for one year, be given insane McDavid minutes (which they both were) and then reap the rewards in free agency a year later.

Barrie went and tested free agency. Nobody was willing to give him as much money as we were for term, so he was forced to stay here.

Kane went and negotiated with other teams and ALSO found out nobody else was going to give him the money we were offering, so he stayed.

It's so funny reading the cope in here with people thinking these guys are here at a discount because they love the city and want to win. No, they played mercenary roles and are now still here because we gave them the most cash. Nobody wanted Kane, nobody was willing to give Barrie 4.5 mil a year because nobody else could give him endless PP minutes with McDavid and Draisaitl.

Again, the ONLY player who has taken an actual discount to stay here long term as a proud Oiler is Nuge. He might disappear in the playoffs, but he is the one and only on the current team who left money on the table to try and win. Good on him.
 

McAsuno

Registered User
Jul 10, 2013
26,899
35,130
Edmonton
The only players who come here 'on a discount' are mercenary types who are here to ride shotgun with McDavid, earn a contract, and then try to leave.


'
The sense is that Barrie is going to test the free-agent market. He's earned that right and given everything that Ken Holland and the Oilers are going to have to go through with hefty negotiations with Larsson, Nugent-Hopkins, Darnell Nurse, and others, you need to be able to compare apples to apples.

Tyson Barrie would very much like to stay in Edmonton but he also wants some stability. We're talking about a five- or six-year term, so most likely, he goes to the open market to see what the bigger picture looks like as well.

'


'
The Edmonton Oilers have granted Evander Kane permission to speak with other teams before the NHL’s free agency period opens and Colorado’s Nicolas Aube-Kubel went from celebrating with the Stanley Cup on Saturday to not receiving a qualifying offer from the Avalanche on Monday.

70c8fc80

In a text to The Associated Press, Kane’s agent, Daniel Milstein, wrote he’s opening talks with other teams while also continuing discussions with the Oilers with his client eligible to become an unrestricted free agent on Wednesday.


'

The only player in my memory who took a cut to play here is Nuge. This is like the people talking about how Brown signed here for ONLY 775k and what a great guy he is, wanting to come here and win a Cup. No, we are paying him 4 million and no other team in the league was ever going to give him that much.

Coincidentally with the two links I posted, neither of those guys chose to play here on a discount to try and win a championship. They both signed here due to a lack of options with the cap not rising in COVID times. They signed here because they had their contracts terminated or they thought an opportunity would arise where they could play here for one year, be given insane McDavid minutes (which they both were) and then reap the rewards in free agency a year later.

Barrie went and tested free agency. Nobody was willing to give him as much money as we were for term, so he was forced to stay here.

Kane went and negotiated with other teams and ALSO found out nobody else was going to give him the money we were offering, so he stayed.

It's so funny reading the cope in here with people thinking these guys are here at a discount because they love the city and want to win. No, they played mercenary roles and are now still here because we gave them the most cash. Nobody wanted Kane, nobody was willing to give Barrie 4.5 mil a year because nobody else could give him endless PP minutes with McDavid and Draisaitl.

Again, the ONLY player who has taken an actual discount to stay here long term as a proud Oiler is Nuge. He might disappear in the playoffs, but he is the one and only on the current team who left money on the table to try and win. Good on him.


russell-westbrook-yawn.gif

Nobody got time to read all that crap.
 

SupremeTeam16

5-14-6-1
May 31, 2013
8,205
7,435
Baker’s Bay
The only players who come here 'on a discount' are mercenary types who are here to ride shotgun with McDavid, earn a contract, and then try to leave.


'
The sense is that Barrie is going to test the free-agent market. He's earned that right and given everything that Ken Holland and the Oilers are going to have to go through with hefty negotiations with Larsson, Nugent-Hopkins, Darnell Nurse, and others, you need to be able to compare apples to apples.

Tyson Barrie would very much like to stay in Edmonton but he also wants some stability. We're talking about a five- or six-year term, so most likely, he goes to the open market to see what the bigger picture looks like as well.

'


'
The Edmonton Oilers have granted Evander Kane permission to speak with other teams before the NHL’s free agency period opens and Colorado’s Nicolas Aube-Kubel went from celebrating with the Stanley Cup on Saturday to not receiving a qualifying offer from the Avalanche on Monday.

70c8fc80

In a text to The Associated Press, Kane’s agent, Daniel Milstein, wrote he’s opening talks with other teams while also continuing discussions with the Oilers with his client eligible to become an unrestricted free agent on Wednesday.


'

The only player in my memory who took a cut to play here is Nuge. This is like the people talking about how Brown signed here for ONLY 775k and what a great guy he is, wanting to come here and win a Cup. No, we are paying him 4 million and no other team in the league was ever going to give him that much.

Coincidentally with the two links I posted, neither of those guys chose to play here on a discount to try and win a championship. They both signed here due to a lack of options with the cap not rising in COVID times. They signed here because they had their contracts terminated or they thought an opportunity would arise where they could play here for one year, be given insane McDavid minutes (which they both were) and then reap the rewards in free agency a year later.

Barrie went and tested free agency. Nobody was willing to give him as much money as we were for term, so he was forced to stay here.

Kane went and negotiated with other teams and ALSO found out nobody else was going to give him the money we were offering, so he stayed.

It's so funny reading the cope in here with people thinking these guys are here at a discount because they love the city and want to win. No, they played mercenary roles and are now still here because we gave them the most cash. Nobody wanted Kane, nobody was willing to give Barrie 4.5 mil a year because nobody else could give him endless PP minutes with McDavid and Draisaitl.

Again, the ONLY player who has taken an actual discount to stay here long term as a proud Oiler is Nuge. He might disappear in the playoffs, but he is the one and only on the current team who left money on the table to try and win. Good on him.
I don’t even need to read the opinion of a dullard to know that it’s…
3CD00733-745D-4700-8DFD-E0931FB1A85B.gif
 

bobbythebrain

Registered User
Jul 30, 2016
13,711
13,229
The degree to which Nurse is overpaid is greatly exaggerated. If he was at $8-8.5M he would be a solid value for what he brings to the table. He makes mistakes but the results when he is on the ice are overwhelmingly positive.

He is still top 30 in points for a defenseman, 7th for goals, 12th in ES points and 3rd in Es goals for defensemen over the last 3 years. He is also 8th in +/- so the idea that he bleeds goals against is way overstated especially given the tough minutes he plays. His contract right now is not the reason the Oilers are up against the cap. The only really bad deal the team has is Campbell at $5M for the way he played last year.

He's been a mess in 3 playoffs now.
He had a covid season which really boosted his stats and status.
He's decent in regular seasons, but very underwhelming in the playoffs.

He's overpaid by atleast 2.5mil if you exclude the CCHL season(Canadian Covid Hockey League) in which he stacked his stats
 

VainGretzky

Registered User
Jun 4, 2015
13,466
11,541
The only players who come here 'on a discount' are mercenary types who are here to ride shotgun with McDavid, earn a contract, and then try to leave.
JMO but ever since you got ridiculed for the Taylor Hall was building a house and returning your whole posting in here changed from a reasonable poster to stirring the pot for some type of revenge or something. I would just chill and go back to being reasonable :thumbu:
 

OG Eberle

Registered User
Aug 25, 2011
1,571
1,976
The only players who come here 'on a discount' are mercenary types who are here to ride shotgun with McDavid, earn a contract, and then try to leave.


'
The sense is that Barrie is going to test the free-agent market. He's earned that right and given everything that Ken Holland and the Oilers are going to have to go through with hefty negotiations with Larsson, Nugent-Hopkins, Darnell Nurse, and others, you need to be able to compare apples to apples.

Tyson Barrie would very much like to stay in Edmonton but he also wants some stability. We're talking about a five- or six-year term, so most likely, he goes to the open market to see what the bigger picture looks like as well.

'


'
The Edmonton Oilers have granted Evander Kane permission to speak with other teams before the NHL’s free agency period opens and Colorado’s Nicolas Aube-Kubel went from celebrating with the Stanley Cup on Saturday to not receiving a qualifying offer from the Avalanche on Monday.

70c8fc80

In a text to The Associated Press, Kane’s agent, Daniel Milstein, wrote he’s opening talks with other teams while also continuing discussions with the Oilers with his client eligible to become an unrestricted free agent on Wednesday.


'

The only player in my memory who took a cut to play here is Nuge. This is like the people talking about how Brown signed here for ONLY 775k and what a great guy he is, wanting to come here and win a Cup. No, we are paying him 4 million and no other team in the league was ever going to give him that much.

Coincidentally with the two links I posted, neither of those guys chose to play here on a discount to try and win a championship. They both signed here due to a lack of options with the cap not rising in COVID times. They signed here because they had their contracts terminated or they thought an opportunity would arise where they could play here for one year, be given insane McDavid minutes (which they both were) and then reap the rewards in free agency a year later.

Barrie went and tested free agency. Nobody was willing to give him as much money as we were for term, so he was forced to stay here.

Kane went and negotiated with other teams and ALSO found out nobody else was going to give him the money we were offering, so he stayed.

It's so funny reading the cope in here with people thinking these guys are here at a discount because they love the city and want to win. No, they played mercenary roles and are now still here because we gave them the most cash. Nobody wanted Kane, nobody was willing to give Barrie 4.5 mil a year because nobody else could give him endless PP minutes with McDavid and Draisaitl.

Again, the ONLY player who has taken an actual discount to stay here long term as a proud Oiler is Nuge. He might disappear in the playoffs, but he is the one and only on the current team who left money on the table to try and win. Good on him.

You posted thousands of words and none of them added up to "I was wrong about my point".

All you did here was move the goal posts.

Stop doubling down. Either skulk away into the darkness like you seemingly did before or own up that you had a shit take that was disproven very easily. Nothing you said here remotely changes that.
 

Fourier

Registered User
Dec 29, 2006
25,769
20,332
Waterloo Ontario
Anything less than the Draisaitl contract would have worked for me. Therefore 8.5M wouldn't have worked because of the team cap structure, not to mention the ancillary issues that come from Nurse making more than Draisaitl. It was not only a bad contract from day one it was a poor organizational move.

It doesn't matter to me what Jones contract was. Chicago went all in and lost. We weren't forced to follow suit.

Maybe I'm wrong but that's a standard I set and I was furious the second the Nurse contract was announced. It should have been accept less than Draisaitl and that's the bottom line.

I never had a problem with the Draisaitl contract from day one.


An athlete being criticised for being overpaid is completely fair game.

I also blame Holland for handing out a bad contract. He should be ridiculed. Also fair game.
The fact that Draisaitl was at $8.5M was almost completely irrelevant as far as a ceiling on the Nurse deal was concerned. Draisaitl's deal ends after the 2024-2025 season. Nurse's deal ends 5 years later than that. By the time Nurse's deal is up Leon will have been getting paid much more for half a decade, which is what he deserves.

The real issue is that the team used two bridge deals to set up Nurse in the best bargaining position he could have asked for. There is no way they could let him walk without a viable replacement which they did not have. Yes they would have had cap space. But cap space is only as valuable as what you can get for it. Teams were locking up all their top defenders so it's not like they would have easily replaced him.

No one is arguing that Nurse's deal was a good one. But $1-1.5M more than what one might have reasonably expected hardly requires ridicule. Especially, when Holland had essentially no leverage. He could have rolled the dice and waited. But had he done so there was an even money chance that it would have ended up worse. Now part of this is on him since he gave Nurse the second bridge. And no one will argue that Holland's strength is cap management. But the real culprit in the Nurse contract is Chia. He set the tone with the first bridge and his brutal cap management that set Holland up with little wiggle room for the second bridge.

 
  • Like
Reactions: WaitingForUser

ujju2

Registered User
Apr 9, 2016
9,669
6,555
Edmonton, AB
Barrie went and tested free agency. Nobody was willing to give him as much money as we were for term, so he was forced to stay here.
Probably more accurate to say the Oilers couldn't afford to re-sign both him and Larsson, and chose Larsson over him. When that fell through, we circled back to Barrie, who was always willing to stay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: guymez

WaitingForUser

Registered User
Mar 19, 2010
4,716
4,517
Edmonton
The fact that Draisaitl was at $8.5M was almost completely irrelevant as far as a ceiling on the Nurse deal was concerned. Draisaitl's deal ends after the 2024-2025 season. Nurse's deal ends 5 years later than that. By the time Nurse's deal is up Leon will have been getting paid much more for half a decade, which is what he deserves.

The real issue is that the team used two bridge deals to set up Nurse in the best bargaining position he could have asked for. There is no way they could let him walk without a viable replacement which they did not have. Yes they would have had cap space. But cap space is only as valuable as what you can get for it. Teams were locking up all their top defenders so it's not like they would have easily replaced him.

No one is arguing that Nurse's deal was a good one. But $1-1.5M more than what one might have reasonably expected hardly requires ridicule. Especially, when Holland had essentially no leverage. He could have rolled the dice and waited. But had he done so there was an even money chance that it would have ended up worse. Now part of this is on him since he gave Nurse the second bridge. And no one will argue that Holland's strength is cap management. But the real culprit in the Nurse contract is Chia. He set the tone with the first bridge and his brutal cap management that set Holland up with little wiggle room for the second bridge.
Agreed including the Edmonton tax he is at the most 1.5 overpaid. It’s not as bad as people want to make it out to be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Positive

Broberg Speed

Registered User
Oct 23, 2020
7,231
4,906
The fact that Draisaitl was at $8.5M was almost completely irrelevant as far as a ceiling on the Nurse deal was concerned. Draisaitl's deal ends after the 2024-2025 season. Nurse's deal ends 5 years later than that. By the time Nurse's deal is up Leon will have been getting paid much more for half a decade, which is what he deserves.

The real issue is that the team used two bridge deals to set up Nurse in the best bargaining position he could have asked for. There is no way they could let him walk without a viable replacement which they did not have. Yes they would have had cap space. But cap space is only as valuable as what you can get for it. Teams were locking up all their top defenders so it's not like they would have easily replaced him.

No one is arguing that Nurse's deal was a good one. But $1-1.5M more than what one might have reasonably expected hardly requires ridicule. Especially, when Holland had essentially no leverage. He could have rolled the dice and waited. But had he done so there was an even money chance that it would have ended up worse. Now part of this is on him since he gave Nurse the second bridge. And no one will argue that Holland's strength is cap management. But the real culprit in the Nurse contract is Chia. He set the tone with the first bridge and his brutal cap management that set Holland up with little wiggle room for the second bridge.
I don't share the positive outlook towards Darnell Nurse that you do. I would have let him walk if he didn't accept ~8.25M. Less than Draisaitl. You don't think that was a kick in the junk to Draisaitl? It upset the pay structure and there needs to be a team hierarchy, and the pay scale is definitely a component of that.

Some players are always going to be levels above other players in many facets on a professional hockey club. Nurse wears the A and he's technically reverting in his defensive skills. This is unacceptable.

I'd strip the A off of Nurse and give it to Ekholm for this upcoming season to demonstrate that the level of his defensive play is unacceptable. Ekholm deserves it more. He's the most sound player on the Oilers if not the damned division. That sort of handling is a necessary part of competitive professional sport.

You have to work harder and perform at a higher level than the other players to maintain your place in the pecking order. The only excuse I will accept for Nurses' play is the man-on-man coverage that is coached. It doesn't matter that his partner was Ceci. Nurse needs to play better and last seasons playoffs isn't a one off either. He has been a vulnerable point for the Oilers in all of the playoffs he's appeared in.

I'm disconcerted sufficiently over the lack of NHL level structure demonstrated, against Vegas in particular, I'd like to see Woodcroft fired.

Be damned with his regular season record. Who's to say we wouldn't have beaten Vegas with more competent coaching? Difficult to win a Stanley Cup with that nonsense no matter who they add to the roster.

The organization should honestly look to Mattias Ekholm for advice on the future direction of the coaching staff. If Ekholm told you a certain coach is one of the best he's ever seen and he's available you wouldn't think long and hard about this players evaluation?
 
Last edited:

nabob

Big Daddy Kane
Aug 3, 2005
34,835
21,586
HF boards
I don't share the positive outlook towards Darnell Nurse that you do. I would have let him walk if he didn't accept ~8.25M. Less than Draisaitl. You don't think that was a kick in the junk to Draisaitl? It upset the pay structure and there needs to be a team hierarchy, and the pay scale is definitely a component of that.

Some players are always going to be levels above other players in many facets on a professional hockey club. Nurse wears the A and he's technically reverting in his defensive skills. This is unacceptable.

I'd strip the A off of Nurse and give it to Ekholm for this upcoming season to demonstrate that the level of his defensive play is unacceptable. Ekholm deserves it more. He's the most sound player on the Oilers if not the damned division. That sort of handling is a necessary part of competitive professional sport.

You have to work harder and perform at a higher level than the other players to maintain your place in the pecking order. The only excuse I will accept for Nurses' play is the man-on-man coverage that is coached. It doesn't matter that his partner was Ceci. Nurse needs to play better and last seasons playoffs isn't a one off either. He has been a vulnerable point for the Oilers in all of the playoffs he's appeared in.

I'm disconcerted sufficiently over the lack of NHL level structure demonstrated, against Vegas in particular, I'd like to see Woodcroft fired.

Be damned with his regular season record. Who's to say we wouldn't have beaten Vegas with more competent coaching? Difficult to win a Stanley Cup with that nonsense no matter who they add to the roster.

The organization should honestly look to Mattias Ekholm for advice on the future direction of the coaching staff. If Ekholm told you a certain coach is one of the best he's ever seen and he's available you wouldn't think long and hard about this players evaluation?
That’s a lot of words.
 

CantHaveTkachev

Legends
Nov 30, 2004
50,555
31,152
St. OILbert, AB
The degree to which Nurse is overpaid is greatly exaggerated. If he was at $8-8.5M he would be a solid value for what he brings to the table. He makes mistakes but the results when he is on the ice are overwhelmingly positive.

He is still top 30 in points for a defenseman, 7th for goals, 12th in ES points and 3rd in Es goals for defensemen over the last 3 years. He is also 8th in +/- so the idea that he bleeds goals against is way overstated especially given the tough minutes he plays. His contract right now is not the reason the Oilers are up against the cap. The only really bad deal the team has is Campbell at $5M for the way he played last year.
Get outta here with stats
He made mistakes a few times!
 
  • Like
Reactions: nabob

McTonyBrar

Registered User
Apr 2, 2018
18,510
19,398
  • Like
Reactions: Duke74

Mcnotloilersfan

I'm here, I'm bored
Jul 11, 2010
11,091
5,161
Niagara
Which of these 3 Scenarios (all of which would be incredibly helpful) do you think is most likely?

1) Skinner/Soup give us adequate playoff goaltending
2) Broberg or Ceci play well in the 2RD role.
3) Holloway breaks out, easily slides in to the top 6 anytime an injury occurs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad