Doctor No said:
But you're from Pennsylvania (according to your nameplate, at least). Why should I trust your opinions on the viability of Atlanta as a future hockey town?
Well, you certainly don't have to, they are opinions after all.
But Atlanta is perceived as a notoriously poor sports town. The NHL failed there once, so at least I have a historical foundation to fall back on. I can also point to the abysmal TV ratings in the Atlanta area for their playoff series against NY. In a time when bad ratings stories are not that uncommon, that one was very sobering. If I'm correct it was just a few thousand households in the Atlanta area that bothered watching the series on TV. That isn't even headscratching bad. That's jaw agape, eyes wide-open and unblinking bad. This was the Number Three seed in the playoffs, the winner of their division. And almost nobody watched their series in their own hometown.
To answer your question, if hockey succeeds in Atlanta or Miami, then it can do quite well. On the other hand, we have a Winnipeg supporter admitting that NO MATTER WHAT, Winnipeg will be below the median. Do you see the difference?
I'm not sure how to answer that first line. It's almost akin to saying that if pigs could fly, they could fly very far. But they can't, so they won't. Well, hockey is not succeeding in those two places. Not by a long shot. Now it's just a matter of how long the owners want to keep throwing money at it.
As to the Winnipeg person, I think they were being very realistic. I'm not sure how you can say that teams at or near the bottom in attendance and revenue deserve chance after chance, but when someone comes and says that Winnipeg could jump up to the middle of the pack they are derided. Ask the owners of some of those teams if they'd take middle of the road versus what they have now year after year. My guess is that they'd be on it in a heartbeat. So what if Winnipeg will never be number one. I have news for all of you, neither will Florida or Atlanta - despite the capacity of their arenas.
So in this case putting the game in a place where it will be appreciated is far better, even if it does mean that it will never be a Detroit or Toronto. I'd rather watch 15,000 screaming fans in Winnipeg than 13,000 (2,000 of whom came dressed as empty seats) docile customers in Miami.