Ranking Teams Prospects

[Mrb1p]

WTH we just drafted Tkachuk,we already have a 30 point rookie nhl defender in Chabot...Bowers isnt on the team,and Gruden is no where close to guys like Formenton,White,Docker and Gustavsson

Yeah and none of them are center prospects.

And true, forgot about Bowers, that puts you guys down.

I guess White would qualify as a prospect, thought he had more games.

 

[LarKing]

Yeah, I don't have the numbers worked up, sorry. Make it half, make it the whole board, it's the same thing. Id say that the whole draft crew (About 20 of us, who exchange scouting reports, etc,) wanted Kotkaniemi but one person.

No that’s not the same thing. Your argument changes by the post - a good indication you’re making things up as you go to fit your argument.

 

[Garthinater]

Is that response in the troll playbook?

Don't feed elias pettersson, anyone that has to say "I'm not a troll" is definitely a troll. Just ignore him, it's the best way to handle posters like that.

 

[Mrb1p]

No that’s not the same thing. Your argument changes by the post - a good indication you’re making things up as you go to fit your argument.

Oh, questioning my integrity again, instead of countering my argument.

 

[LarKing]

Oh, questioning my integrity again, instead of countering my argument.

I’m not questioning your integrity. I’m questioning your argument, which is not consistent. I think you’re a good poster, but your argument has been all over the place in this thread.

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

A prospect ranked around 14 made the Devils last year at 19, these lists never seem to predict success. For all we know LA has 3 or 4 mid level prospects emerge as quality top end players.

 

[topshelf15]

Yeah and none of them are center prospects.

And true, forgot about Bowers, that puts you guys down.

I guess White would qualify as a prospect, thought he had more games.

lol ,cant tell if you are being serious here.....

 

[Mrb1p]

lol ,cant tell if you are being serious here.....

The list was especially for centers, I dont get your point.

 

[topshelf15]

The list was especially for centers, I dont get your point.

Brown,White ,Batherson and even Chlapik are centers.....So I dont
get your point

 

[topshelf15]

So we doing winger prospects next???How about defense??,Goaltending????We have a bunch of good ones in each of those positions as well....

 

[topshelf15]

Ottawa,s prospect pool is >>than MTL

 

[Mrb1p]

Ottawa,s prospect pool is >>than MTL

Yeah, if you think Brown is a good prospect and if you think Tkachuk is equal to Kotkaniemi you might think so... doesnt mean youre right.

Also, do you really think the Sens have better G prospect than the Habs? McNiven, Primeau and Lindgren?

 

[topshelf15]

Yeah, if you think Brown is a good prospect and if you think Tkachuk is equal to Kotkaniemi you might think so... doesnt mean youre right.

Yep so 1 prospect that may or may not be better than the dozens we have,makes MTL that much better???You wanna compare defenders next???Ill see your Mete and raise you a Chabot....Uhh Gustavsson??

 

[Mrb1p]

Yep so 1 prospect that may or may not be better than the dozens we have,makes MTL that much better???You wanna compare defenders next???Ill see your Mete and raise you a Chabot....

Chabot is not a prospect anymore, if not, you might have had a point.

 

[topshelf15]

Chabot is not a prospect anymore, if not, you might have had a point.

Neither is Mete,or is it because Mete,s 7 points in 49 games was easily trumped by Chabot,s 25 points in 63 games and his 9 goals as apposed to 0 for Mete

 

[topshelf15]

So Gustavson isnt a good goalie prospect now???Who knew??

 

[Elias Pettersson]

Don't feed elias pettersson, anyone that has to say "I'm not a troll" is definitely a troll. Just ignore him, it's the best way to handle posters like that.

Hey man, that's a personal attack! Don't hurt my feelings like that
I have never trolled in my life so I dont even know what trolling is.

 

[topshelf15]

So wingers next???Tkachuk and Formenton are two I throw out first...MTL,s answer would be??

 

[Mrb1p]

Neither is Mete,or is it because Mete,s 7 points in 49 games was easily trumped by Chabot,s 25 points in 63 games and his 9 goals as apposed to 0 for Mete

Mete is likely to back to AHL this year, Chabot is a full time NHLr.

 

[Mrb1p]

So wingers next???Tkachuk and Formenton are two I throw out first...MTL,s answer would be??

Ive already stated the Habs have meh winger depth. Scherback and Ylonen are our two best.

 

[Mrb1p]

So Gustavson isnt a good goalie prospect now???Who knew??

I never said Goose isnt a good goalie prospect, Hogberg is fine too. Goalie depth is comparable, I think the wild card is Primeau.

 

[topshelf15]

Mete is likely to back to AHL this year, Chabot is a full time NHLr.

Lol ,just admit MTL doesnt have the depth that Ottawa does and move on bud...MTL is working on it sure, but Ottawa,s is better...In the end what does it matter???We both sucked ass..And we will likely sell off every decent piece we have for more prospects...Because we have the league,s worst owner

 

[Mrb1p]

Lol ,just admit MTL doesnt have the depth that Ottawa does and move on bud...MTL is working on it sure, but Ottawa,s is better...In the end what does it matter???We both sucked ass..And we will likely sell off every decent piece we have for more prospects...Because we have the league,s worst owner

I really dont think the Habs have bad depth at all. Guys like Fonstad and Harris are PPG rookies in OHL/WHL and they are not even in our top ten.

The sens have good depth too, to be fair, they just dont have the top end with Chabot graduating, picking Brown, Tkachuk and White middling.

And TBH, Id much rather have a Chabot, anyway, so I dont know why youre so upset. Hes a good player, even if im not as high as some on him.

 

[topshelf15]

I really dont think the Habs have bad depth at all. Guys like Fonstad and Harris are PPG rookies in OHL/WHL and they are not even in our top ten.

The sens have good depth too, to be fair, they just dont have the top end with Chabot graduating, picking Brown, Tkachuk and White middling.

Yep and i can too list others like Docker,Jaros,Harpur,Englund Wolanin,Tychonic just on defense....But,those dont count??And why is Mete considered a prospect to you playing 49 games,while Chabot isnt while playing only 63???

 

[topshelf15]

Basically,MTL has 1 center prospect, that trumps our 4 center prospects....Every other position could be argued we beat them in ,and MTL,s pool is better??