Things do need to change in a big way. That doesn't absolve Sid of his significant part in our struggles though - his performance in our elimination series simply hasn't measured up to his role or his pay grade the last few years.
He's been an afterthought, even relative to his teammates. Staal was our best offensive player against Philly, and Giroux embarrassed him. Sid was useless against Boston...Cooke was our best forward, and Malkin was at least generating chances. Freakin' Dubinsky was outplaying Sid in the CBJ series, and what's worse, Richards didn't even chase that match-up after awhile. Now Sid's mailing it in again this series outside of one or (if we're generous) two games.
His performances are far from our only issue, but I'm not going to attribute all Sid's problems to the organization - I think too much of his talent for that. Crosby's not playing like this because of the system, or the coach, or his teammates. Other Pens are playing well over that period. Lesser players. Current linemates. In the end, he's accountable for his play.
I called Crosby out after the Boston series, as well as Malkin. However, he still had 8 points in the Philly series. I put that series mostly on MAF. He lost his mind in that series, but once again my point all along has been that Toews lost his mind as well, but his coach and his team straightened him out and carried him when he flipped.
Crosby doesn't have that luxury.
This org has tried to stick with the status quo for far too long, even though things clearly aren't working.
With the concussion saga, busted jaw, inept coaching, crap goaltending, Olympic pressure, and shift by shift abuse, I think he's just worn out mentally and physically. Like I said, it happens. He's human.
So I'm not defending his play, but I'm defending the fact that he is a champion, and there are other factors at work that should have never happened, that have him in this state. Tons of people are turning on him and I'm simply not going to do that.
Derrick Pouliot does it pretty regularly.
I do think the Pens can win a Cup with Neal. But not with Neal playing on a different line than Sid and Geno, which that 7 goals in 37 games stat doesn't take into consideration. I'll be the first to admit that Neal's relatively useless when he's not playing with an elite center. If we don't plan on using him in that role moving forward, we should deal him.
A lot of junior players dick around and play lazy. If DP brings his non-chalant attitude to the NHL, I'll call him out as well. For now, he is in juniors and Neal is a 26 year old, "star" NHLer.
IMHO Neal is a third wheel that can score goals. I don't see how he can be considered a core player. If there are big changes, he has to be one of the guys who is on the block and if there is a good deal to be made, Shero needs to pull the trigger.
Neal is the poster boy for what's wrong with this org.. the complacency, the laziness, the selfish and stupid play. It needs to stop.
The culture needs to change, it really does.