BarbaraAlphanse
Guest
oh good,you have excuses ready for players you like
FWIW, I didn't think Kevin would have nearly as big of an impact as he did last year. I was kind of down on him.
oh good,you have excuses ready for players you like
I forget who said it in the game thread but the Rangers breaking camp with 8 defensemen makes sense if they are thinking about trading Klein.
Diaz and Bellemore are not the answer though. Bodie and McIlrath?
SUMMARY:
The BEST:
-MCl - Was out BEST Dman
-Lingberg - Great 2nd period, and OK 1st and 3rd.
-Miller - GREAT 1st, ok 2nd, and ok 3rd.
The GOOD:
Etem - VERY good game all around, good defensive, good physically, good offensively.
Stalberg - good all game, nothing GREAT but did what he had to.
Stoll - Will be a good 4th liner center. Bye bye Moore?
The Bad:
Hart
Graves
The Worst:
Diaz
Kabanov
Obviously we'll have to agree to disagree Fly but serious question. What is it that you see in Etem that no one else sees? I just don't get it.
I love and miss hockey but that game made me want to gouge out my eyes and never watch it again.
That said:
Lindberg- a New York Ranger. He was the best player on the ice for the Rangers. I know that's saying zero but still. The puck followed him around all night, unfortunately so did some of his teammates.
McIlrath- was ok, with more ice time I think he can be decent. I didn't think he had a great game but he wasn't bad. Quite frankly he was paired with a tomato can most of the night.
Diaz- was hot garbage.
Klein, meh squared.
Graves is not ready for the NHL but has promise.
Kabanov- he has a neck tattoo, get rid of him.
Hayes, Miller were non existent, I think Hayes is still in Norway. Miller had a good first period, I think he went to the bathroom to poop and missed the 2nd and 3rd. Incidentally, when he's on the ice with Bodie, I think Olympic Skiing.
Nejwhatever- see Graves, although he was very skilled at times.
Bourque- Didn't see much out of him. I mean he played but you need to see more for him make the team.
Bodie- A puck magnet like Lindberg. He has some potential. You can't teach a player how to be around the puck that much. I know he's older and small as the Keebler elf but again if he can develop some maybe he can be a Rafalski type guy. Look that's humongous "if" I know. For some reason he impressed me tonight.
Stalberg- He looked decent paired with Lindberg, at least that line didn't totally suck like the other 3.
Etem- Is it possible to go back in time and get Carl Hagelin back? Dare to dream.
Stoll- Watching him take a face-off, I can really see what drew Erin Andrews to him. He makes faceoffs an art form.
Diaz- My god he sucks.
Adam- Who?
Hart- played like Owen.
Diaz- wow awful.
Raanta- stood on his head for about 20 seconds and then let in a bunch of goals.
Hellberg- He has a cool name.
Please blow up this lineup card and hope to hell it's never conjured up again.
I thought we should have given Gibbons another look instead of wasting everyone's time on Kabanov.
Your brand of comedy may not be for everyone but the bolded is why you're on of my favorite posters on here
Agree with all your assessments too.
Lindberg -Moore-Stalberg would be a phenomenal 4th line, but you gotta assume Glass is playing any time McIlrath sits because AV will want a designated fighter in the lineup.
I thought we should have given Gibbons another look instead of wasting everyone's time on Kabanov.
Kabanov led his Swedish team in points per game among forwards (a defenseman was the overall leader). The SHL is one of the top leagues in the world, on part with the AHL. Obviously the Rangers wanted to see what he's got. I'd give him one more game to see if tonight was just nerves.
Guys who are already NHL regulars are rarely any good in these games because it's a warmup to them where other guy's seasons are on the line.
Hayes sucked tonight imo but I don't care at this juncture.
My concern with Klein is that this is going all the way back to the playoffs.
First you tell us that McIlrath's corsi numbers sucked then you tell us the guys who are NHL regulars play like ******* in exhibition games so I'm wondering how all those NHL regulars playing like crap effected McIlrath's corsi numbers because they were on the ice with Dylan a lot. Maybe you could explain that?
Other posters have said he played well. So please dont say its JUST me. Either you were expecting him to play like Kreider, or you were expecting him to be a AHLer(so u looked for every little play to rip on him).
Tonight: Etem > Hayes , just saying (obviously Hayes is BETTER, but if we are judging on ONE game)