Our bottom six is pretty much a patchwork quilt with no real design to it. That's a big problem in my opinion. We haven't built a lineup. We've acquired and developed good pieces, but I don't see any evidence of any plan as to how it all fits. The top six, at least, there are a bunch of combinations that mostly use the same pieces and overall, all of the options are solid enough that something has to click or hot stretches have to be found, but the bottom six in particular has no purpose or defined structure. What kind of line is Kreider, Boyle, Pyatt? What kind of line is Boyle, Rupp, Pyatt? I like Pyatt but I'm not sure why we brought him in, when I think about it. Why didn't we go for someone specifically geared to be in a third line shutdown role?
I think it could well turn up true that we were better off without Nash, even though I think Nash has been our best player most of the time this season.
Pyatt/Kreider - Richards - Gaborik
Hagelin - Stepan - Callahan
Dubinsky - Anisimov - Kreider/Pyatt
Rupp - Boyle - Asham
I'm not sure if the difference in the quality of that bottom six over what we have now is worth Nash or not. Hopefully things click, but we are more top heavy than ever. Meanwhile, our defense seems really rusty. And there's a huge possibility that Hagelin and Callahan both over performed offensively last year (Callahan was never expected to put up those kinds of numbers) and that Kreider's playoffs were a flash in the pan as well. Not saying Kreider or Hagelin are going to be busts or anything, but Hagelin probably won't produce at the rate he did last year and Kreider probably needs more time. Last year could easily have been a career year for Callahan offensively. Taking all that into consideration, we're not nearly as deep a team as we might have thought. Furthermore, I wasn't impressed with Richards last season more often than I was. He was good, but not as good as our fan base made him out to be. This season he's flat out infuriating me and he looks tremendously out of shape, IMO. He probably will improve as the games go on, but he certainly won't be improving as the seasons go by. Something to think about. This team is still missing a legit bottom pairing defender and a forward that solidifies the bottom six and gives it some cohesiveness, IMO. We may also need to put Hagelin in the bottom six, send Kreider down and think about cheap, rental options for the top six to give us depth that we evidently don't have.
And finally, I think we can ask some questions about the teams commitment level during this long off-season. Nash was obviously ready to go. I think Gabby looks refreshed too. But I'm thinking either a lot of guys didn't think there was going to be a season and took it easy or weren't working out like they fancy themselves serious contenders this year because the team just looks overall flat and in need of conditioning.
I'm confident we're a playoff team. I'm confident that by the time the playoffs roll around, we'll have sorted a lot of things out, guys will have gotten their legs, their chemistry, their timing... whatever it is they need to sort out. I'm confident that we're still a good team in the long run and we can get hot at the right time. I don't think this is the best team in the league by a long shot though, and I do think there are some things that need to be addressed.