Manny Malhotra is 60% for his career
And he's absolutely awful. So therein lies my point.
It's situational and it's insane how big people are on it. Ron Francis was great at faceoffs and he said he didn't care if he won or lost faceoffs in the neutral zone. Why? Because you are almost always going to get possession again before you can allow a goal, so throw out half the draws players take right there.
Then you have the O and D zones where the stat actually does have merit, but you're still dealing with comparing player X at 49% and player Y at 55%......over the course of 82 games! Plus you have the reasoning above which doesn't hold as much weight in your own zone or the other team's, but it's still a factor. I'd love to know how many times the offensive team wins a draw and it results in either a blocked shot or a dump down the boards. I bet it's at least 80% if not 90%.
It's a stat people obsess over that has too many other variable to worry too much about, unless you have a guy winning at a 30% clip or something. Honestly if a guy is at least at 45% I really don't care. Slightly less than that is something the player needs to work on, but the worry ends there.
Thank you, UB, for bringing rationalization and logic to this discussion. It's much appreciated.
That's a 21 man roster. Full rosters are 23. It's unlikely the Pens start the season with anything less than 22, likely 23. So your cap space should be closer to like, nothing.
We just went through all kinds of shenanigans this season because of the cap. We, of all teams, can never assume reasonably good health on the roster (even with Kessel).
So we better damn send a couple of more contracts out of town before the season begins. I don't want to be the laughingstock of the league again.
If Sutter can bring back something of value, sure. But no NHL team is going to give away a guy who can score 20 goals in this league.
Nobody is talking about giving Sutter away. Trading him for draft picks that we have in short supply still is not giving him away. Sending him in a hockey trade obviously isn't giving him away, either. Trading his contract to create more cap space isn't giving him away either.
There are plenty of motivating factors to ship Sutter.