This is a real good story, if there is no room now on the roster how are they magically going to play their way back up? an injury? so they have to earn their call up on the hope of someone being injured on the roster?
Also those 3 guys can boost an overall roster, those 3 guys are definitely difference makers over Pomminville, Okposo, Berglund, Bogosian, Sobotka, Tennyson, Beaulieu. Do you honestly think just Dahlin and Thompson can change our woes from last season? If you do, than you should have no problem thinking those 3 could do the same thing.
Reinhart and Eichel couldn't carry this team last year with O'Reilly and Berglund and Sobotka are the not the difference to fill the gap that O'Reilly made when he was ripped away by management.
Essentially the team makeup is the exact same except maybe worse.
The X Factors: Skinner and Sheary, except Sheary doesn't have a good center to play with, struggling Mittlestadt or Berglund is his choice and Skinner is essentially replacing Kane's production.
Well first of all, literally any team any year has all kinds of injuries, so it's not a matter of hoping, it's a matter of when we have to start digging into our depth. And the answer is usually within a couple/few weeks.
Second of all, we have no proof of your second paragraph w.r.t. any of those guys, especially Asplund, who was exposed when Pittsburgh's NHLers were half-assing their way to domination against us, rightfully so. He was in over his head at that point, and it was pretty clear to me at least that he needs a bit of seasoning before he's ready for a full-time jump. And that's totally fine and expected. The fact is, the couple games of ~18 minutes of ice time we got to watch from these guys in the preseason really aren't as indicative of as much as we'd think, and recalling preseason warrior Derek Grant from two years ago should be enough to dissuade those notions.
Now, I would have kept both Pilut and Nylander from what I've seen, which includes about 4 of the 7 games and zero seconds of practice time. However, in the most recent real hockey Alex has played, he was benched because of his effort and intensity. I have zero issue with the coaching staff saying "great camp Alex, go and show us it's for real and you'll be back before you know it." That's hardly the worst adversity he's going to face in the next three months, much less his career if it's any career worth caring about. I have zero issue with them wanting Pilut, who is a good player but who also had more growing pains than I ever saw mentioned on this forum in the preseason games to go with his exciting bits of promise, to spend some time seasoning at 22 years old as well. They'll all be up sometime soon (maybe a little later for Asplund) and, like I said, it'll be
really goddamn soon if their effect is so strong as to turn the tide of the season.
There are enough young kids in the lineup that I'm not melting down the way I would if Tage and Casey followed these guys to the AHL. as of now, this to me looks like a decent setup, if slightly marginally worse (again, we have no real game proof of this at all) than it could be for the first couple of weeks.
And FTR, I don't believe Dahlin and Thompson will be doing a huge amount to make us a better team (they do make us a better team, it's the degree which I'd disagree with probably plenty of people) until later on in the season, which is part of why I was one of the people gutted by the ROR trade