My issue with Phil has always been his place on PP1, and his complete and utter lack of a forecheck. I mean, I like that we have a guy who doesn't go all-out in regular season games, but he doesn't go at all sometimes.
He should REALLY be placed on PP2 though. Utterly pointless to run the puck through the worst puck handling forward we have when you have Geno, Sid, Letang, and Hornqvist out there. Watching him bobble the play 1-4 times per night is just cringe worthy. Guentzel would be far more effective and on PP2 you could have Phil or Schultz be our second-ditch efforts. Guentzel is also far superior at making contact with the puck on hard passes. Every opposing team knows to hone in on Phil the moment he touches the puck. Not a coincidence that Sid is left all alone since nobody would dare go 1 on 1 with him when they're already down a man. Phil's forecheck speaks for itself though.
As others have pointed out: if he isn't getting you that every-other-game breakaway or wrister, he isn't giving you much at all. It's not like Geno where opposing teams have to choose how to deploy their D - pretty sure I've seen fourth lines face Phil this year; and they did so with ease.