Somewhere between bobby9 and puckmunchkin is the correct take on Petey. He can do wrong and needs to step up and be better. He also isnt the worst thing ever
So, here’s my actual take on EP40. I like the player a lot. He has very high end skill, but he seems to always have some sort of issue plaguing him. Whether it’s motivation, sulking, injuries or something that requires a sports psychologist.
So, what is he actually? He definitely is NOT a superstar. I think because the Leafs have Matthews and Oilers have McDrai most Canadian franchises want desperately to have their own superstar. We have an inferiority complex. The Canucks management, fans and local TV/Radio guys have built him in to this superstar he really isn’t.
He very very rarely takes over games. He almost never wills us to victory himself and he leaves a lot of physical attributes to be desired. When the team has great chemistry and is clicking he can put up points, but when the team is in a rut, unlike McDrai and Matthew’s he simply cannot put the team on his back.
Nate, McDrai, Crosby, Matthew’s, Kuch etc are all in their own tier. People want EP40 to desperately belong to that tier of players but he simply doesn’t.
I don’t even know if he belongs in the tier below those players. The second tier has Rantanen, Matty T, Point etc.
I’d have him aligned with Aho, Rintz, Zib, Stutzle, Larkin, Robertson, McCann. 3rd tier stars.
He leaves to many things to be desired to often. Fans simply want him to belong to the top tier so we can say our franchise has a superstar.
He’s over paid by 2.6 M dollars next year.