Mr Jiggyfly
Registered User
- Jan 29, 2004
- 34,316
- 19,391
Heatley would drive the net when there was no resistance. But so would Neal. If anything, he works harder now that he's slow and awful than he did when he was in the cup finals. In addition, his depreciation has been most-frequently explained by unwillingness to do offseason training, not back problems or whatever.
I could count on one hand the times I ever saw Neal drive the net with the puck. Heatley had his shortcomings, but the guy wasn't afraid to take the puck to the net or stand in front to tip shots or bang in rebounds.
Franzen's had a lot of injuries, but he was jekyll and hyde before that when it came to work and hustle (I saw him in a SEL game years ago on the international channel and was floored that the same guy made the NHL years later). It's speculated in Detroit that this is due to psychological problems, not injuries. Whatever the cause, it leads to the sort of half-assing that you see from Neal, though it's not an every game thing. Babcock's on his case a lot. If Brainless had been on Neal like Babcock is with Franzen, would he have improved? It's at least possible.
Until his injuries really derailed his career, Franzen played hard in just about every game I ever saw in the NHL, and that was quite a few. He was also money in the playoffs and found another gear, unlike Neal.
OV and Pacioretty are smack in the middle of the players you mentioned and the players I mentioned. No, they're not as lazy as Neal (though OV's boardwork is every bit as poor...if he doesn't get to the puck first or free it up with a bodycheck, he all but quits on the play), but they're a far cry from the likes of Stamkos or Perry when it comes to battle-level.
I'm not going to defend AO as some great two way threat, but he most certainly works much harder than Neal in the attacking zone. With Patches, we obviously aren't going to agree. He's pretty much nothing like Neal.
The only guys as I said who are like Neal, are guys that can't seem to play to an acceptable level that makes their coaches and even teammates in Semin's case, happy.