I don't know about that... I thought that McDavid's pp goal was pretty weak. Murray had time to square up and got beat 7-hole. In a show down of "great goalie vs great shooter" it was still a stoppable shot and it wasn't. All things relative of course, but when I let in a 7-hole goal and I was square and ready, I'm still pretty pissed with myself, even if it is the best shooter in the league.
As far as I saw it:
Goal 1 Pitts: Crosby deflection from 2 feet to the side of the net. Talbot's out to cut the angle, so there will definitely be space behind him and it was well exploited. Good goal.
Goal 1 Oil: Drai snipes a shot over the pad (stick side) from just above the hash marks. Nice shot, can't really blame Murray cuz while he was set, it was a scrambly play with a little traffic..., but on a perfect night he might have that.
Goal 2 Oil: Chaisson picks up a funny rebound off a skate and snipes it bar down while falling. Murray isn't getting that.
Goal 2 Pens: Oleksiak finishes a three man passing play shooting five hole. Talbot's a bit deep and not quite square. That's probably his weakest of the game.
Goal 3 Pens: Bang-bang play from behind the net and the pass is deflected. Talbot is down early and is deep, but that can happen if he's playing the "untipped" pass. The deflection throws timing off, but you'd still like him a little more agressive on that (either tipping the pass or pushing off the post to the top of the crease). I agree he has that when he's on his game.
Goal 3 Oil: Chiasson from Reider. Great goal, no blame.
Goal 4 Pens: Hornquist goal. We discussed already... no fault of Talbot. Just what are the defense trying to do on that play? Clearly not much other than cause traffic and fail to clear rebounds on two very nice saves.
Goal 4 Oil: McDavid 7 hole on the power play. As I said above... weak. As weak as goal 2 for the Pens and weaker (in my goaltending opinion) than goal 3 of the pens.
Goal 5 Oil: Drai from McDavid... Murray isn't stopping that.
Goal 5 Pens: Crap defending leading to a free slapper on goal while 5 oilers are between Talbot and the puck... three of them between his eyes and the puck and nobody does a darn thing other than back in so he can see even less. If any of you are defenders, this is the type of goal that makes your goalie lose his marbles. If you aren't going to do anything, get out of the way! I place zero blame on Talbot for this one.
Breakaway in OT? Talbot has it. There's your payback for his weakest goal.
Goal 6 Pens: Crosby's individual effort. Talbot tracks him across properly (unlike Nurse who doesn't recognize the danger of having Crosby challenge Strome) and poor Strome who simply loses his jock strap. Can't blame Talbot on this one... I'd probably like to see Nurse switch checks with Strome once that play comes down low... poor team play/awareness there.
If you want to assign "blame" on goals, then the score was either 2-1 Pens victory or 2-2, depending on whether you think Murray should stop Drai's first goal.
So did Murray play a better game? Sure, he had plenty more action, but did Talbot "lose" the game on the basis of having fewer shots? No way.
Note to Oilers: if you want to be a GOOD team, you must still win when your goalie is outplayed. If you have a mid-tier starter (which Talbot is) that's going to happen (on average) 40-60% of the time. Are we just going to concede those games and blame it on goaltending? What a cop-out.... everybody shows up to the rink knowing Murray is a better goalie, just like everyone knows Letang is better than any of our D, and Kessel better than any of our wingers... you deal with it. That's what teams do!