The COO and CMO have little to do with your complaints. I'll give them more time to figure it out. You can go and write them off already
I think the underlying sentiment is that while they can put together a new campaign, slogans, messaging, graphics, uniforms, improve game experience, etc, etc. all of this does not equate to rebranding. A brand is not the marketing campaign. A brand is "the intangible sum of a product’s attributes" - David Olgilvy.
Or maybe better put, “A brand is not a logo. A brand is not an identity. A brand is not a product. A brand is a person’s gut feeling about a product, service, or organization.” - Marty Neumeier.
New promotional strategy is not going to change the gut feelings of many sens fans across the market right now. You have to change the internal culture across the board of the organization so that every outward communication and move made by the organization reflects what you want the brand to represent. <<<This will take a long, long time IMO for a COO and CMO to impact given that the people above them that led to the current perception of the brand are still in place.
It's not about writing them off as much as setting realistic expectations.