three dog night
Registered User
- May 3, 2014
- 5,092
- 1,331
It will cost a lot for Thomas
Agree that Thomas will cost a lot including a player. I wonder if Peric could be that player though as they get two and probably three years from him which would fit with their rebuild. Another factor to consider is Niagara needs picks. Their cupboard is bare ( got some back today) and they lost a first rounder so they need seconds. All I'm saying is they could be open to a mostly picks deal. Also I believe Peric is from the general area if I remember right so could be a fit.Yup. It wouldn't be reported if it wasn't true. It means they understand they have holes and want to fill them.
The "problem" is Akil Thomas is one of those high value players. That IS NOT a draft pick only trade.
This is one of the reasons why I'd like Ottawa to keep Peric for the time being. He's potentially a body that other teams can count on providing some sort of reasonable oimpact this year as well as next with a strong possibility of an OA year.
If we trade him for picks, that's fine but impact 19 yo players at the deadline are not available for picks (typically).
No argument here, hell of a player! Wonder what the dogs are looking for. They need picks badly especially with losing a first rounder. If they want a 16 y.o. they need to wait until the deadline but the danger in that is a buyers market and you end up selling low...see Owen Sound last year! So do they take a deal now if its decent or wait for more at a risk? Ottawa also might not wait and move to plan B so a big buyer is out of the equation.It will cost a lot for Thomas
I say trade him has early has possible.No argument here, hell of a player! Wonder what the dogs are looking for. They need picks badly especially with losing a first rounder. If they want a 16 y.o. they need to wait until the deadline but the danger in that is a buyers market and you end up selling low...see Owen Sound last year! So do they take a deal now if its decent or wait for more at a risk? Ottawa also might not wait and move to plan B so a big buyer is out of the equation.
Agree that Thomas will cost a lot including a player. I wonder if Peric could be that player though as they get two and probably three years from him which would fit with their rebuild. Another factor to consider is Niagara needs picks. Their cupboard is bare ( got some back today) and they lost a first rounder so they need seconds. All I'm saying is they could be open to a mostly picks deal. Also I believe Peric is from the general area if I remember right so could be a fit.
It will cost a lot for Thomas
Niagara will have two high end 16yr olds on defence this year in Isaac Enright and Landon Cato. I imagine the Dogs would be after a 17 year old forward and a boatload if picks. Or wait until deadline time where they would hope to pry 1st rounder out of a contender plus picks. Any 18 year old shouldn’t interest the Dogs as it would make no sense for a rebuild timeline.I doubt Peric would be a centrepiece. He's simply not good enough. I'm not sure how deep Niagara is on the blueline but Costantini has zero chance with Ottawa once everyone is back. He's a possibility as a filler if they need depth on D. Yule is also on the outside looking in as we start to bulk up the Forward group with trades. So we do have some "spare parts" that can be included but at the end of the day, Niagara needs a centrepiece. To me that is one of Matier, Robinson or Tolnai. If they cannot get one of those three, there is no real reason to trade now.
Niagara will have two high end 16yr olds on defence this year in Isaac Enright and Landon Cato. I imagine the Dogs would be after a 17 year old forward and a boatload if picks. Or wait until deadline time where they would hope to pry 1st rounder out of a contender plus picks. Any 18 year old shouldn’t interest the Dogs as it would make no sense for a rebuild timeline.
The Dogs recently named Thomas captain. I don’t see them dealing him before he’s played a game with the C on his chest. The Dogs desperately need to get a teams first round player. They’re short a lot of high end picks, add losing a first round pick for getting caught cheating, it’s imperative they get one.
I would expect Thomas to be dealt at the deadline.
Sirizotti and the other 16 y.o. cannot be dealt this year. Only our first rounder (Matier) can be dealt in a window in early January.It makes no sense for Niagara to entertain any moves at this point. The smart thing for them would be to wait until at least November to see who is out there and what is available. Sirozzoti could also be part of a deal if they are looking at the future.
For Tolnai to be part of a deal he would need to show that he can play at the level
I believe Thomas is a center so maybe they move Hoelscher to left wing. So a top 6 ofI’m thinking more along the lines of Clarke or Quinn. No point having 3 top-6 right wingers.
I am legit scared to know what the cost of Thomas would be.
Peric + 2 x 2nds + 3 x 3rds?
OMG- why do you keep throwing Robinson out there as a trade chip? What HS kid would agree to waive his NTC to come to a top team in his draft year and then waive his NTC again a few weeks later? It would likely be atrocious for his draft stock to be moved twice in two months.
Trading either Clarke or Quinn feels like robbing Peter to pay Paul in a go for it year. I can't see the team moving either, as both will be big this year and be MAJOR trade chips next year in the OHL Mem Cup year.
It seems like our D (Peric, Belanger or Matier) are the most likely trade chips, along with possibly Tolnai and Yanic Crete (if he is willing to move his NTC as a french speaking HS kid). Yule is the perfect 4th line player as a tough, hard working program player- not sure what the point of dealing him would be? Would Will Cranley be a trade chip in his draft year to get more games?
Assuming we do trade for Thomas indicating a go for it year, the Robinson trade makes little sense. Either the brass liked him so much they couldn't pass or they acquired him to use as a trade chip?
One other option is moving highly ranked prospect Colby Ambrosio (Niagara native) as a centrepiece. Look at the Maksimovich (Swankler) and Dipietro (Afanasyev) deals from last year as a precedent.
Good point, hadn't thought of that. In the same vein Dylan Peterson could also be an asset. Looks like a first rounder in the NHL draft this year. Could be directed to the O.One other option is moving highly ranked prospect Colby Ambrosio (Niagara native) as a centrepiece. Look at the Maksimovich (Swankler) and Dipietro (Afanasyev) deals from last year as a precedent.
I'd be very reluctant to trade Belanger ...but you do have to give something. I'd offer Peric, Crete, picks and rights to Ambrosio.I think Belanger and Crete plus 4-5 picks works for both teams. I am guessing that Niagara gave out two gold packages this past draft to their two drafted RD so Tolnai may prohibit Niagara from luring a kid leaning towards school in the next couple of drafts? An extra gold package can be valuable as the ice dogs forfeited their 2020 1st pick?
I'd be very reluctant to trade Belanger ...but you do have to give something. I'd offer Peric, Crete, picks and rights to Ambrosio.
I do get your point but two things. IMO Peric is not a bottom pairing D. He played there because of our depth. He's been stuck behind Bahl/Hoef/Rippon/Okhotiuk and Wilson. He's at present a top four and imo has the potential to be a top pairing guy as a 19/20 y.o. He also has a decent chance to play an OA year. Now I get that the Dogs are likely looking at 21-22 season to contend so what you do you give Peric plenty of icetime and if he comes back as an OA you likely have a top pairing guy in a contending year. If he plays too well, gets drafted/signed and it looks like he's not back for an OA year you trade him to a contender and get assets for the following year. If he develops well you will get a good return.Peric doesn’t make any sense from a Niagara perspective. They don’t need a bottom pair 18 yr old. They have two OA’s on the back end to help develop the two 16 yr olds. They are in the first year of a major rebuild. An 18 yr old doesn’t serve any purpose to them. 17 yr olds and picks or wait until the deadline for a 16 yr old and picks.