Killer made the deals that created this team. Did the players let him down at times. IMHO yes.
Killer had the belief that the OHL was there to develop players and to bring exciting hockey to Ottawa every year.
You can chirp all you want about whether he was a great GM but i personally would say that yes he was. He found players in later rounds that others missed.
He drafted and developed teams that year in and year our were contenders and brought exciting hockey to Ottawa.
Why was it Couture came to Ottawa. Simple once he missed the top he said it ws the only team he would play for
Remember also that the owners that Killer worked for did not want to break the bank for this team and it was a very frugal set up.
Most teams get lucky now and then with players deep in the draft; however, if we are speaking in general terms, the top 5 draft picks usually make the team. Outside the top 5 rounds, there were not many players that made an impact in Ottawa. You can list them if you want but I could also list many other team's picks outside the top 5 rounds that made an impact.
I would suggest that Killer's coaching ability is what made the impact. It was his ability to tap into what made a player tick and bring out the best in that player.
The Ottawa 67's lost in the finals in 1997, 1998, 2003, and 2005. Each of those years other than 2005 the 67's should have and could have won the OHL Championship. They had contender type teams in 1996, 1999, and 2000 as well. they won the Championship in 2001. Killer was unwilling to make the sort of deals necessary to put his teams over the top.
When the 67's were in the crapper, he refused to trade the likes of Joslin, McGinn, Couture etc to give the team the necessary boost the following year. We continued to dwell in the basement with no hope of getting out.
This league is dedicated to the development of hockey players and that is true; however, the individual teams should be in business to win championships. Settling for mediocrity or just above for the sake of player loyalty is, in my opinion, a flawed way of operating a team.
As long as players are given an opportunity to develop their skills and not just play defense first, the obligation is being met on behalf of the team. I hate when teams install systems of defense that shackle the players ability to create offensively. Killer never did this as a coach. I loved that about him. I think Killer exceeded all expectations to the player as a coach but as a GM he did a disservice to the hockey fans of Ottawa.