Let's be honest aside from the miracle cup run that duo struggled before 2006 as well. They were missing the playoffs half the time and getting bounced in the first round. 2006 saved their jobs IMO.
Take out the magical cup run and I didn't think Mact was that good and he was coach for what, 8 years? Wasn't that a record? It took him way too long to step down, and katz probably told him to bow out for a few years. Considering that I bet we're stuck with Lowe and Mact for many more years.
That being said I like Mact as a gm more than a coach even though he's been mind bogglingly blind to the centre situation. We need a new coach ASAP, Eakins is terrible, maybe worse than Quinn.
Oh yeah, they were terrible, and ridiculously unprofessional to boot. The Christmas day practices and the Comrie affair(he resigned in edm like a week after Mact left) to name a couple.
A lot of current Oiler fans weren't fans of the franchise prior to the cup run though. They don't remember Mact losing the room in the first two years as coach(prompting a bunch of popular players getting shipped out), the never ending downgrade trades for magic beans(behavior that continued after the lockout), and a team that steadily got worse the more time Mact/Lowe had to put their stamp on the core that Sather put together. They remember the cup run though, and that has given the duo of suck far more rope with which to hang themselves than they ever should have had.
Not sure why you'd be a fan of Mact as Gm though. In addition to attaching his ego the Eakins hire, the only thing he seems interested in acquiring is mediocre yet expensive wingers(Clarkson offer, Purcell, Pouliot, Hendrick). The best of his acquisitions is Perron, another winger who doesn't address any of the Oilers crippling issues at center and defense.
Speaking of defense - Larsen, Grebeshkov, Belov, Nikitin, Ference, Hunt, Fayne, Fraser acquired, Smid given away for nothing, Petry on the verge of getting shipped out for picks <-- if that is not a list that scares you going forward when it comes to Mactavish's ability to assess defensive talent and put together a successful defensive core... it really should.