Steve Kournianos
@thedraftanalyst
People always say this once other 3 years or so and it never comes true. In 2003, only 7 players drafted in the second round played 400+ games (5 full seasons). In addition, Jimmy Howard should count even though he played fewer games because he's a goalie. B.J. Crombeen will also reach 400 games since he's still in the NHL. That's 9 players or 30%.
In a regular draft, 20% of second rounders make it, in a super-draft it's 30%. From 20 to 30 is an increase in half, so it's very significant, but people still exaggerate what "a good draft means."
A guy drafted around #15 has about a 50-50 chance of playing in the NHL, maybe slightly more, so a #15 in an average draft has double the odds of making it than a second rounder in a tremendous draft.
It never comes true because it's a hypothetical scenario.
Brodeur, Tkachuk and Smolinski were the last three picks of the 1st round. Where would they have slotted in the much weaker 1991 and 1989 drafts?
The 2014 draft was weak. The scouts were saying it for two years. GMs are never going to say "well, this draft sucks but we drafted kids because we had to". The scouts are the ones who were pretty unanimous in that the 2014 draft was going to be a gamble draft, not a cornerstone draft.
2015 is a great, great pool. I would rank it behind 1979, 1984 and 2003 but ahead of 1990.