Well that's what I am thinking too but apparently guys like Flashy and Shaman have a different opinion on it and that's fine. We might be overrating abby's impact but to me, like you said, his impact was real!
Nyquist on the other hand seemed very invisible and I really hope he can learn "playoff" hockey. I think he showed he can perform under pressure when Z and Dats were injured 2 years ago and scored an insane amount of goals, I'm confident he will translate this into playoff success!
Like Flashy said, he's not the first guy to struggle in his first few playoff games.
I thought he (and Tatar) got better as the series went on. They weren't necessarily rewarded on the score sheet, but I thought they were taking the body more consistently, and going to the harder areas of the ice. They weren't shying away from the play.
I also think Abdelkader had a noticeably positive impact when he came back. His physical play and ability to go in against Tampa's bigger D was big for us. But it's also something we shouldn't be expecting so much out of Nyquist who is, what, three inches and thirty pounds smaller? Nyquist definitely needs to be more productive in the playoffs, but he's not going to go out there and consistently rail guys like Sustr and Coburn.
The kids that disappointed me the most were Sheahan and Jurco. They are some big boys, and they needed to put those big frames to more use.