Noahhabib's GM Game V1.0: Sign-Up & Discussion

[BruinsNeedaRussian]

skimmed through your post but parenteau > steen

No way. Steen is elite defensively and Parenteau could easily be the case of a player thriving on a weak team.

Plex is a much better player than Ribeiro though.

 

[caps4cup]

No way. Steen is elite defensively and Parenteau could easily be the case of a player thriving on a weak team.

Plex is a much better player than Ribeiro though.

Ehh they are definitely close. Pleks is better 2 way, but his production has increased and decreased alot over the years from the 40's, to 70, to the 30's, to 70 again, then to the high 50's, then to the low 50's. Whereas Ribeiro has constantly been in the 70-80 point range. With MSL and Semin he'd score 85 points at least. But they are definitely close and it's probably just opinion, as I'd take him over Plekanec, but I wouldn't disagree with people who thought Pleks>Ribeiro. I'd only disagree if they thought one was way better than the other.

 

[KesselLooksLikeRadar*]

Ehh they are definitely close. Pleks is better 2 way, but his production has increased and decreased alot over the years from the 40's, to 70, to the 30's, to 70 again, then to the high 50's, then to the low 50's. Whereas Ribeiro has constantly been in the 70-80 point range. With MSL and Semin he'd score 85 points at least. But they are definitely close and it's probably just opinion, as I'd take him over Plekanec, but I wouldn't disagree with people who thought Pleks>Ribeiro. I'd only disagree if they thought one was way better than the other.

I'm sorry, but did anyone else notice that he said Semin = Benn?

I get you think he might score "85 points", but remember that MSL played with Stamkos, a sniper, so you'd have to rely on Semin to score the majority of goals on that line... Something I would rely on Benn more, IMO.

Also, you can't compare Ribby and Pleks, two very different players. If you had a two way system, you'd take Pleks EASILY. If you had a run and gun system, you'd take Ribby EASILY.

ALSO, because I'm too lazy to find the quote, TB, you did lose the Hedman trade, but, it doesn't mean that you lost every trade afterwards. See our Staal trade and the move I made after as an example of that.

 

[caps4cup]

I'm sorry, but did anyone else notice that he said Semin = Benn?

I get you think he might score "85 points", but remember that MSL played with Stamkos, a sniper, so you'd have to rely on Semin to score the majority of goals on that line... Something I would rely on Benn more, IMO.

Also, you can't compare Ribby and Pleks, two very different players. If you had a two way system, you'd take Pleks EASILY. If you had a run and gun system, you'd take Ribby EASILY.

ALSO, because I'm too lazy to find the quote, TB, you did lose the Hedman trade, but, it doesn't mean that you lost every trade afterwards. See our Staal trade and the move I made after as an example of that.

Benn played with Eriksson and Ryder.
Semin played with Perreault (didn't even play in playoffs) and Chimera (former 4th liner). And not surprisingly, they both had career years. Look at Semin's stats and see how ridiculous some of his point totals are. In 08/09, he scored at a 95 point pace. In 09/10 he scored at a 105 point pace. All with no 2C and a 50 point Brooks Laich. Now imagine him playing with MSL and Ribeiro. AND Semin plays a good 2 way game and can PK.

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

Official Ruling:

are NOT DQ'd

Despite several comments that they Shoud be, they will not be disqualified

 

[PaulSedin]

Official Ruling:

are NOT DQ'd

Despite several comments that they Shoud be, they will not be disqualified

i'm not in this game but why not

they didn't follow the rules
i'm sure if other teams knew they could get away with being over the cap they would have been better

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

i'm not in this game but why not

they didn't follow the rules
i'm sure if other teams knew they could get away with being over the cap they would have been better

He said he made a trade that put him back under the cap. If there is evidence to support that he did not make this trade, than the Flyers will be DQ'd.

 

[BruinsNeedaRussian]

Ehh they are definitely close. Pleks is better 2 way, but his production has increased and decreased alot over the years from the 40's, to 70, to the 30's, to 70 again, then to the high 50's, then to the low 50's. Whereas Ribeiro has constantly been in the 70-80 point range. With MSL and Semin he'd score 85 points at least. But they are definitely close and it's probably just opinion, as I'd take him over Plekanec, but I wouldn't disagree with people who thought Pleks>Ribeiro. I'd only disagree if they thought one was way better than the other.

Doubt anyone hits 85 on the second line these days without being truly elite. Should definitely beat Plex in points, but doesn't blow him out of the water offensively. Plex is worlds better defensively though.

Voting for you either way this round, but are you switching back to a offensive system?

 

[caps4cup]

Doubt anyone hits 85 on the second line these days without being truly elite. Should definitely beat Plex in points, but doesn't blow him out of the water offensively. Plex is worlds better defensively though.

Voting for you either way this round, but are you switching back to a offensive system?

More offensive, yes, but not like 09-10. The Caps will look to be a leader in goals for, but won't slouch defensively. It also helps to play more offensively now, since through 08-10 the Caps never really had a good defense or goalie, now they have very good ones.

 

[BruinsNeedaRussian]

More offensive, yes, but not like 09-10. The Caps will look to be a leader in goals for, but won't slouch defensively. It also helps to play more offensively now, since through 08-10 the Caps never really had a good defense or goalie, now they have very good ones.

Third line will help immensely in the backend.

 

[caps4cup]

Third line will help immensely in the backend.

Yep true. And Backstrom, Semin, MSL are all good 2 way forwards. And that 4th line is great.

 

[Gaborikthebeast]

He said he made a trade that put him back under the cap. If there is evidence to support that he did not make this trade, than the Flyers will be DQ'd.

He's over That's the end honestly he should be

 

[Wesleyy]

He said he made a trade that put him back under the cap. If there is evidence to support that he did not make this trade, than the Flyers will be DQ'd.

can you be more specific?

 

[glasgow26]

I'm disappointed my Sharks lost. Definitely thought we'd make an appearance in the SCF. Congrats to the Blues!

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

The are officially DQ'd from the Stanley Cup Playoffs due to a cap violation that was not fixed. Due to many GMs stating that they should be disqualified, I chose to reconsider my decision.
After a while of deciding, I have chosen to disqualify the Philadelphia Flyers.

The automatically advance to the EC Conference Finals.

 

[wreckingcru]

The are officially DQ'd from the Stanley Cup Playoffs due to a cap violation that was not fixed. Due to many GMs stating that they should be disqualified, I chose to reconsider my decision.
After a while of deciding, I have chosen to disqualify the Philadelphia Flyers.

The automatically advance to the EC Conference Finals.

We are sorry for what happened. had a good team and we are sad to see them go like that. However, here we go Eastern Conference Finals!

 

[KesselLooksLikeRadar*]

We are sorry for what happened. had a good team and we are sad to see them go like that. However, here we go Eastern Conference Finals!

See? I could have been harsher last game

 

[Wesleyy]

The are officially DQ'd from the Stanley Cup Playoffs due to a cap violation that was not fixed. Due to many GMs stating that they should be disqualified, I chose to reconsider my decision.
After a while of deciding, I have chosen to disqualify the Philadelphia Flyers.

The automatically advance to the EC Conference Finals.

shouldn't the bolts play the rangers? i don't think it would be fair for tampa bay if Rangers are automatically advanced.

 

[AccuracyFive]

These playoffs are a joke. Yes I lost and I am a little pissed but its not like I lost to a completely **** team. The Rangers have an excellent team however the standings in the first place were messed up. No offense, but how did Montreal win the division?

 

[Matty K]

The are officially DQ'd from the Stanley Cup Playoffs due to a cap violation that was not fixed. Due to many GMs stating that they should be disqualified, I chose to reconsider my decision.
After a while of deciding, I have chosen to disqualify the Philadelphia Flyers.

The automatically advance to the EC Conference Finals.

How I'm under the Cap after the Gagne Trade do the math figure it out!

I can't believe the whining from some of you guys in this game

Its a ****** computer game for christ sakes

 

[Matty K]

Corey Perry's cap hit is $5,325,000 not $5,150,000 look who's over the Salary Cap now Bud sorry!

I can play that game too

 

[Wesleyy]

FORWARDS $40.055m
Jason Spezza ($7.000m) / Pavel Datsyuk "C" ($6.700m) / Johan Franzen ($3.955m)
Jiri Hudler ($2.8m) / Henrik Zetterberg "A"($6.083m) / Valtteri Filppula ($3.000m)
Colin Greening ($0.817m) / Colin Wilson ($2.3m) / Cal Clutterbuck ($1.400m)
Raffi Torres ($1.75m) / Andrew Cogliano ($2.3m) / Chris Neil ($2.000m)
DEFENSEMEN $23.215m
Erik Karlsson ($9m) / Nicklas Lidstrom "A"($6.2m)
Ian White ($2.875m) / Niklas Kronwall ($3.000m)
Jared Cowen ($1.265m) / Brendan Smith ($0.875m)
Filip Kuba ($0.9m)
GOALTENDERS $3.12m
Jimmy Howard ($2.250m)
Robin Lehner ($0.870m)

Total: $67.29m
Cap space: $0.01m​

Lines | Average Points Per Game | Total Points | Hits
Forwards 1st | 0.913 | 207 |
Forwards 2nd | 0.757 | 185 |
Forwards 3rd | 0.44 | 99 | 520
Forwards 4th | 0.347 | 60 | 487
| | |
Defence 1st | 0.725 | 112 | 101
Defence 2nd | 0.43 | 68 | 182
Defence 3rd | 0.355 | 24 | 234

Vote

 

[wreckingcru]

Corey Perry's cap hit is $5,325,000 not $5,150,000 look who's over the Salary Cap now Bud sorry!

I can play that game too

Yeah so i made a mistake for the cap, calm down bud I am just trying to have fun, I edited it now, and lucky for me, i miscalculated the cap in the first place, and I actually had 201,666 in cap before, so that change of 200,000 still keeps me under cap. Let's not get gutty bro, doesn't bode too well on people.

 

[Wesleyy]

Yeah so i made a mistake for the cap, calm down bud I am just trying to have fun, I edited it now, and lucky for me, i miscalculated the cap in the first place, and I actually had 201,666 in cap before, so that change of 200,000 still keeps me under cap. Let's not get gutty bro, doesn't bode too well on people.

just a reminder, you changed it to 5.35, its actually 5.325

 

[wreckingcru]

thanks