Proposal: Noah Hanifin and James Neal for Kyle Palmieri

[Sparky93]

Hannifin and Santini were defensive pair in college.

Were they paired together, thought it was McCoshen? Johnny and Santini also played together there.

 

[nickdawg95]

He's also turning 32 before the start of next season. How many players that age have ever been traded for a 1st, blue chip prospect, and a roster player?

I guess it depends on how you define "blue chip" project. Typically that term is applied to the top 20 or so prospects in the league. Kessel is not bringing that back at his age.

maybe not blue chip, but a Grade A prospect

 

[culturaldingo]

I don't see how New Jersey actually improves with this deal. They don't exactly have top-6 wingers to spare.

You are getting one back in James Neal

 

[devils29]

I’m not the worlds biggest Hanifin fan, but you’re right. Considering age, production, durability and contract, Hanifin is worth significantly more than Palmieri. Hanifin won’t be packaged to move Neal. His value is a lot closer to Hischier than it is Palmieri.

Good god does this site under value Hischier. You have got to be kidding actually thinking that

 

[Sparky93]

Good god does this site under value Hischier. You have got to be kidding actually thinking that

Not at all. Yes, I think that Hanifin’s value is a lot closer to a 2 years younger Hischier than it is a 6 year older, winger Palmieri. Would a straight up deal for Hischier and Hanifin ever happen? Probably not, but it’s far closer than Palmieri.

 

[Lays]

something around Zib + for Raz Andersson++

No

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

I’m not the worlds biggest Hanifin fan, but you’re right. Considering age, production, durability and contract, Hanifin is worth significantly more than Palmieri. Hanifin won’t be packaged to move Neal. His value is a lot closer to Hischier than it is Palmieri.

I'm sorry, what?

 

[Blender]

Since coming to New Jersey in 15-16, Palmieri is the 14th highest scoring right winger in the NHL and 17th in points/game. I wouldn't move him for Hanifin, who I like as a good 2nd pairing defenseman, as it doesn't make our team better.

 

[devils29]

Not at all. Yes, I think that Hanifin’s value is a lot closer to a 2 years younger Hischier than it is a 6 year older, winger Palmieri. Would a straight up deal for Hischier and Hanifin ever happen? Probably not, but it’s far closer than Palmieri.

No. It’s really not.

 

[Volica]

Yeah.
Hanifin =/= Palmieri's value in a 1 for 1 trade.
Like, not close, at all. Hanifin's a young stud D who turned 22 in January. Irregardless of Palmieri's improvement from a 2nd round pick value (and it's higher), how often are under 25 year old stud defencemen moved in general? Let alone for a goal scorer.

I think Kyle's a good fit in Calgary. Not at that cost. Calgary's building something really special on the backend, the only guys I'd move back there are Brodie and Kylington (of course Stone), and that'd be for Palmieri type upgrade.

 

[ManwithNoIdentity]

lol, what are you talking about ? kessel would get a
1st
Top 9 roster player
Bluechip prospect

Just another crazy day on HF

 

[135ace]

I’m not the worlds biggest Hanifin fan, but you’re right. Considering age, production, durability and contract, Hanifin is worth significantly more than Palmieri. Hanifin won’t be packaged to move Neal. His value is a lot closer to Hischier than it is Palmieri.

I think it's fair to say that Hanifin is worth more than Palmieri, but not that much more.
That being said Hanifin is nowhere near close to Hischier's value. If you wanted to trade for Hischier it would cost you Monahan + Hanifin at the very least.

 

[Newsworthy]

Solves problems for both teams.

Calgary needs a top RW and NJ needs a LHD

NJ doesn't need Neal or his contract though.

 

[Alex NJD]

Without looking at Hanafin's or Palmieri's values, Neal just scored 19 points in 63 games, is 32 in September, and is making 5.75 million per year for 4 more years. That contract is atrocious and he has significant negative value in a trade. Don't touch this because of Neal alone

 

[ginovegas]

Habs could use a left handed D, if calgary needs cap relief, how about suzuki plus

 

[Mazatt]

Habs could use a left handed D, if calgary needs cap relief, how about suzuki plus

Would it be a Hanifin + Neal for Suzuki +? If it's just Hanifin then I'd have to figure the Flames ask for a top 6, goal scoring winger with picks going either way, or Montreal adding based on contracts. With Neal idk how Flames get Suzuki + anything but it's a deal I wouldn't be 100% opposed to.