Proposal: Noah Hanifin and James Neal for Kyle Palmieri

[culturaldingo]

Solves problems for both teams.

Calgary needs a top RW and NJ needs a LHD

Click to read more...

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Kessel. Though he’s probably a little older than the Flames would ideally like.

 

[Patagonia]

Nylander -Leafs

For

Hanifin

 

[DakrSnooze]

The word elite gets thrown around so easily nowadays.

 

[MisterT]

Kessel. Though he’s probably a little older than the Flames would ideally like.

Kessel doesn't hold that much value given his age.

 

[culturaldingo]

Nylander -Leafs

For

Hanifin

Do the leafs really need more LD?

 

[Patagonia]

Do the leafs really need more LD?

Not really, but he has a sweet contract, young and can be flipped for a good return. Nylander earns $2M more and this trades provides needed cap relief.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Kessel doesn't hold that much value given his age.

Kessel has plenty value as a ppg winger on a sweet deal, and Hanifin didn’t really do anything to raise his value after being dealt to the Flames.

I understand the age difference, not saying I would necessarily do it from the Flames side.. but I think the value is a lot closer than you make it seem.

Ppg wingers for under 7 mill these days? They don’t grow on trees

 

[dellzor]

Jake Virtanen

 

[bernmeister]

something around Zib + for Raz Andersson++

 

[Mazatt]

Not really, but he has a sweet contract, young and can be flipped for a good return. Nylander earns $2M more and this trades provides needed cap relief.

Both teams need cap relief so imo, trading Hanifin for a guy who will be our highest paid player is questionable.

something around Zib + for Raz Andersson++

Andersson/Valimaki are our closest pieces to being unmoveable, Andersson specifically because he's a young, 20 point rookie on the blue line. As well, he's our most easily controllable player on the right side with Hamonic and Brodie being gone soon. Any trade for Zib from the Flames has to start from another player, even if this is for a #1C.

 

[nickdawg95]

Kessel doesn't hold that much value given his age.

lol, what are you talking about ? kessel would get a
1st
Top 9 roster player
Bluechip prospect

 

[culturaldingo]

lol, what are you talking about ? kessel would get a
1st
Top 9 roster player
Bluechip prospect

HAHAHAHA.

No.

 

[Legion34]

Both teams need cap relief so imo, trading Hanifin for a guy who will be our highest paid player is questionable.



Andersson/Valimaki are our closest pieces to being unmoveable, Andersson specifically because he's a young, 20 point rookie on the blue line. As well, he's our most easily controllable player on the right side with Hamonic and Brodie being gone soon. Any trade for Zib from the Flames has to start from another player, even if this is for a #1C.

As of July 2 nylander would be making 4.9 x 5 in actual money.

Also. Are you not signing hamonic?

 

[nickdawg95]

HAHAHAHA.

No.

Hahaha

PPG Winger signed under 7mil how many of those are in the league ???

 

[Toby Flenderson]

lol, what are you talking about ? kessel would get a
1st
Top 9 roster player
Bluechip prospect

I think that’s probably a little rich I doubt he returns that. Likely only a 1st and like a 2nd line forward for 2nd pair D-man. But to think Noah Hanifin is so much more valuable than Kessel is kinda silly.

 

[QcFlames12]

Who is going to take Gio's place when he declines?

Noah is a no go. Trade Brodie, trade Hammer and trade any other d man before you trade Noah.

 

[culturaldingo]

Who is going to take Gio's place when he declines?

Noah is a no go. Trade Brodie, trade Hammer and trade any other d man before you trade Noah.

Brodie wont get you the player the Flames need. Hamonic is a rare breed and a piece we need. Valimaki can replace Gio, Kylington could be a stud but he needs to play consistently and hone his abilities on the 3rd paid for a couple years.


Hanifin is the most valueable piece the flames have they could actually trade, not significantly hurt the team and get a nice piece back

 

[culturaldingo]

updated I think this would be a good trade for both teams

 

[super6646]

Brodie wont get you the player the Flames need. Hamonic is a rare breed and a piece we need. Valimaki can replace Gio, Kylington could be a stud but he needs to play consistently and hone his abilities on the 3rd paid for a couple years.


Hanifin is the most valueable piece the flames have they could actually trade, not significantly hurt the team and get a nice piece back

Hamonic was a rare bread of suck in the playoffs lol. Your right about Brodie, especially with only a year on his contract. Kylington is not replacing anyone on the roster. If anything, I think he’s our biggest trade chip.

And if your talking about the physical element, hammer had 44 hits. Hanifin had 87.

 

[super6646]

something around Zib + for Raz Andersson++

This one is interesting. Losing Andy will hurt, but I could see a deal if the plus isn’t insane.

 

[Mazatt]

As of July 2 nylander would be making 4.9 x 5 in actual money.

Also. Are you not signing hamonic?

I'm pretty sure his cap hit is 6.9 mil, though, which would give him the biggest cap hit on the team.

The plan is to sign Hamonic, and that would probably work since he wants to be in western Canada, but there's no guarantees.

 

[MichaelJ]

Solves problems for both teams.

Calgary needs a top RW and NJ needs a LHD

Depending on other moves the Devils could make I’d do it one-for-one, want no part of Neal. Don’t think they can afford to part with Palmieri considering their lack of RW depth.

 

[culturaldingo]

Depending on other moves the Devils could make I’d do it one-for-one, want no part of Neal. Don’t think they can afford to part with Palmieri considering their lack of RW depth.

I mean you're gonna have to take Neal in the Deal.

Hanifin for Pal 1 for 1 isn't a good deal. Neal won't really hurt the devils anyway, your rebuilding. He could mentor the kids

 

[MichaelJ]

I mean you're gonna have to take Neal in the Deal.

Hanifin for Pal 1 for 1 isn't a good deal. Neal won't really hurt the devils anyway, your rebuilding. He could mentor the kids

I’d rather add picks or something else than take him on. I don’t see him as a good mentoring influence and I’m not interested in that contract for the next four years.