I haven't watched much of Zads since his departure from Buffalo. Is he a solid top-4 defenseman? Or more of a bottom pairing guy with a ton of snarl?
He is never a solid top4 D.
He oscilates between playing like a top pairing shutdown D for 15-20 games a season and a decent bottom pairing D for 60 games..
He is an amazing 1on1 defender. He really sucks when it becomes a cycle game (Avs in general are not great at defending it but its his biggest weakness) and gets lost puck watching too often...
He also is the absolute king of the Colorado lockerroom :
Ian Cole Diary, Part I: Inside Kadri's goal, bubble life and ... Nikita Zadorov?
Thats why I am surprised but not shocked at how Avs fans are treating him on here.
Its a numbers game and he probably is the odd man out down the road but for some he (and Jost) has become the whipping boys (on a team that has amazing depth where nobody would deserve that label) and some can't wait to get rid off him.
I'd personally would even want to keep him depending on what happens with Byram and Timmins and rather trade Ian Cole (who also isn't half bad).. This seems like a very tight knit group and Zads looks to be the guy hat keeps everyone loose..
Very underrated quality IMO and together with his meanness (although he has dialed it back since his jaw injury) qualities that are not easily replacable...
IMO in the right kind of system (that plays more to his strength and doesn't force him into making too many quick decisions) in the right role Zads could get a lot better and I wouldn't be shocked if he really excelled under a new coach in a new situation...