thestonedkoala
Going Dark
- Aug 27, 2004
- 28,256
- 1,617
Lehtonen32 said:Kovalchuk, Horton, Bouwmeester, Lehtonen, Ovechkin.
And thats just from the Southeast
Here's my 5 not including guys who are already all-stars in the league like Luongo, Kovalchuk, etc...Some may be considered stretches, but I'm also considering other things then pure point scorer's.Senor Rational said:HS then you throw in Heatley, Luongo, Lecavieler, Richards, etc...
felixd said:A journeyman no.1 goalie who has never won anything?
BIGROCKET said:OH...i see....what was I thinking....oh yeah...kind of like the same way Martin Brodeur couldn't compare to Trevor Kidd. Dubnyk has the potential to be the best goalie.....every goalie has that potential. That is the thing with prospects, some of them don't show their true colors (skills) until years down the road. So yeah actually, Dubnyk could be the best goalie prospect out there.
ShadowL said:He didn't vanish in the playoffs, I don't know what the hell your talking about. He scored a nice OT goal in the 2nd game and had a strong first 4 games. The last 3 weren't great, but the whole team blew...
Bergeron IMO, will be a star player in the NHL. He doesn't have elite skills, but he has skills nonetheless to have at least a few PPG seasons. The best thing about Bergeron's potential though is how well of an overall game he's going to have. Future great leader IMO too, will have the ability to lead a team to the Cup. Definite playoff performer.
I also want to make this clear about Bergeron, he will max out his potential whatever it maybe, this guy is a true player. He's the closiest thing to an young Yzerman right now.
Bergeron sophmore slump... I don't think so, no way...
Jay Thompson said:Of course, you look at some of the top picks in Ovechkin, Crosby, and Brule whom will I suspect be something like a bigger Mogilny, a Forsberg, and an Yzerman respectively.
Then you've got some of the top prospects of today. Kari Lehtonen who in my mind is the best goaltender to have come along as a prospect since Jose Theodore. Zach Parise, Ryan Suter, and Dion Phaneuf seem like three guys who could really carry the way for the 'new NHL' if the CBA ever gets resolved.
However, I think the banner will be carried by Kovalchuk. This kid I feel is just above everyone else - that goes for Heatley, Gaborik, Nash, and even goaltender counterparts in Luongo, Lehtonen, or Fleury, and defenseman counterparts in Pitkanen, Bouwmeester, and Kalinin. I think he has the potential to perhaps be put in the same sentence as Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, and Howe. I'm not sure if he has the off-ice personality to be an ambassador for the game (well, Jagr learned after a while there), but on-ice, I feel he's got the skill Pavel Bure, the surliness of Mark Messier, the size of Todd Bertuzzi, and the passion of Steve Yzerman. The kid just burns with intensity, and he, to me, embodies the 'old spirit' of hockey players such as Howe and Richard moreso than any other player today.
Jay Thompson said:Of course, you look at some of the top picks in Ovechkin, Crosby, and Brule whom will I suspect be something like a bigger Mogilny, a Forsberg, and an Yzerman respectively.
Then you've got some of the top prospects of today. Kari Lehtonen who in my mind is the best goaltender to have come along as a prospect since Jose Theodore. Zach Parise, Ryan Suter, and Dion Phaneuf seem like three guys who could really carry the way for the 'new NHL' if the CBA ever gets resolved.
However, I think the banner will be carried by Kovalchuk. This kid I feel is just above everyone else - that goes for Heatley, Gaborik, Nash, and even goaltender counterparts in Luongo, Lehtonen, or Fleury, and defenseman counterparts in Pitkanen, Bouwmeester, and Kalinin. I think he has the potential to perhaps be put in the same sentence as Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, and Howe. I'm not sure if he has the off-ice personality to be an ambassador for the game (well, Jagr learned after a while there), but on-ice, I feel he's got the skill Pavel Bure, the surliness of Mark Messier, the size of Todd Bertuzzi, and the passion of Steve Yzerman. The kid just burns with intensity, and he, to me, embodies the 'old spirit' of hockey players such as Howe and Richard moreso than any other player today.
Jay Thompson said:Of course, you look at some of the top picks in Ovechkin, Crosby, and Brule whom will I suspect be something like a bigger Mogilny, a Forsberg, and an Yzerman respectively.
Then you've got some of the top prospects of today. Kari Lehtonen who in my mind is the best goaltender to have come along as a prospect since Jose Theodore. Zach Parise, Ryan Suter, and Dion Phaneuf seem like three guys who could really carry the way for the 'new NHL' if the CBA ever gets resolved.
However, I think the banner will be carried by Kovalchuk. This kid I feel is just above everyone else - that goes for Heatley, Gaborik, Nash, and even goaltender counterparts in Luongo, Lehtonen, or Fleury, and defenseman counterparts in Pitkanen, Bouwmeester, and Kalinin. I think he has the potential to perhaps be put in the same sentence as Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, and Howe. I'm not sure if he has the off-ice personality to be an ambassador for the game (well, Jagr learned after a while there), but on-ice, I feel he's got the skill Pavel Bure, the surliness of Mark Messier, the size of Todd Bertuzzi, and the passion of Steve Yzerman. The kid just burns with intensity, and he, to me, embodies the 'old spirit' of hockey players such as Howe and Richard moreso than any other player today.
He's easily the game best young player, but not comparable to Jagr(in his prime) yet. Once Kovalchuk wins an art ross with Kip Miller and Jan Hrdina as his linemates, or even wins an art ross, you can compare them. I'm very impressed with his skating and shooting, but his playmaking skills are leagues behind Jagr's. And no, he will not be as dominant as Gretzky.Senor Rational said:Dont forget his skills...he could be as dominate as gretzky. He just keeps getting better and better. He's like Jagr x's 15
Lehtonen32 said:Kovalchuk, Horton, Bouwmeester, Lehtonen, Ovechkin.
And thats just from the Southeast
Jay Thompson said:However, I think the banner will be carried by Kovalchuk. This kid I feel is just above everyone else - that goes for Heatley, Gaborik, Nash, and even goaltender counterparts in Luongo, Lehtonen, or Fleury, and defenseman counterparts in Pitkanen, Bouwmeester, and Kalinin. I think he has the potential to perhaps be put in the same sentence as Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, and Howe. I'm not sure if he has the off-ice personality to be an ambassador for the game (well, Jagr learned after a while there), but on-ice, I feel he's got the skill Pavel Bure, the surliness of Mark Messier, the size of Todd Bertuzzi, and the passion of Steve Yzerman. The kid just burns with intensity, and he, to me, embodies the 'old spirit' of hockey players such as Howe and Richard moreso than any other player today.
Jay Thompson said:Of course, you look at some of the top picks in Ovechkin, Crosby, and Brule whom will I suspect be something like a bigger Mogilny, a Forsberg, and an Yzerman respectively.
Then you've got some of the top prospects of today. Kari Lehtonen who in my mind is the best goaltender to have come along as a prospect since Jose Theodore. Zach Parise, Ryan Suter, and Dion Phaneuf seem like three guys who could really carry the way for the 'new NHL' if the CBA ever gets resolved.
However, I think the banner will be carried by Kovalchuk. This kid I feel is just above everyone else - that goes for Heatley, Gaborik, Nash, and even goaltender counterparts in Luongo, Lehtonen, or Fleury, and defenseman counterparts in Pitkanen, Bouwmeester, and Kalinin. I think he has the potential to perhaps be put in the same sentence as Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, and Howe. I'm not sure if he has the off-ice personality to be an ambassador for the game (well, Jagr learned after a while there), but on-ice, I feel he's got the skill Pavel Bure, the surliness of Mark Messier, the size of Todd Bertuzzi, and the passion of Steve Yzerman. The kid just burns with intensity, and he, to me, embodies the 'old spirit' of hockey players such as Howe and Richard moreso than any other player today.
canada99 said:I don't know too much about Ovechkin or Brule...never saw them play until Ovechkin in World Cup. Crosby I can see being the next Brad Richards, but more physical...If you guys had Jagr in your keeper pool would you trade him for Ovechkin??
Jay Thompson said:Of course, you look at some of the top picks in Ovechkin, Crosby, and Brule whom will I suspect be something like a bigger Mogilny, a Forsberg, and an Yzerman respectively.
DarkHorse said:If you're talking about the next generation of "stars", you have to include Rick DiPietro.
-Cocky
-American
-Good looking
-In New York
-Talented
He's got all the ingredients to become a "star"
Chimaera said:Hopefully I won't spin it to an Ovechkin discussion, but... the quote does raise a question.
Hmm... Ovechkin as a bigger Mogilny, that's interesting. I kinda think he'll have more of a physical game then the underperforming Russian Alexander[read, some of his time with the Canucks ]. If the WC games he played were any example, he's certainly not afraid to take the body. And he certainly is hard to get off his feet (unless he's turning ) But... I'm not sure that appraisal works. For one thing, Ovechkin's not going to be as polished of a sniper, as far as wrist shot and slapper skills are concerned. While I think he'll get his goals with the best of them, I think he's going to earn just as many points on the goalies doorstep as he will in the intermediate shot range which is where Mogilny feasts upon. If you want to compare players, if anything, I think Alexander Semin reminds some more of Mogilny, both in having a quick release, a lot of flash and flair, and also being somewhat of an enigma. A poor man's Mogilny, but similar. However, neither direct comparisons.
Just as I'm not sure the Crosby and Brule accountings work as well. I don't think comparisons really work. Younger players may "look like others" in facets of their games, but they're not exact copies. They may eventually end up getting simlar numbers, but to say they're like, is difficult at best. For another, Crosby better start working harder on his defensive game if he wants to equal Forsberg. And I'm not sure if Brule'll be ready to step in and take over the Captaincy and the teams identity like Yzerman did.
BIGROCKET said:OH...i see....what was I thinking....oh yeah...kind of like the same way Martin Brodeur couldn't compare to Trevor Kidd. Dubnyk has the potential to be the best goalie.....every goalie has that potential. That is the thing with prospects, some of them don't show their true colors (skills) until years down the road. So yeah actually, Dubnyk could be the best goalie prospect out there.
CRAZY_FAN said:If Crosby turns into a Brad Richards a lot of peoples on this board are going to be disapointed...Has for trading Jagr to get Ovechkin, with the possible lockout and the fact that Jagr is not getting any younger, I would do that without hesitating...
Jay Thompson said:Comparables are never 100%, and I don't pretend for them to be. The Mogilny comparison to Ovechkin, I confess, I had trouble finding a good one to compare Alexander to and just slipped Mogilny's in there hoping nobody would call me on it
However, since you did, you're right it's not a very good comparison. I once compared Ovechkin to a bigger Joe Sakic, and I think it works. Off ice, Ovechkin is a very shy person like Sakic, and both have ridiculous wrist shots and 'complete' games. The only difference I might see is that I'm not sure Ovechkin is quite the off-ice leader Sakic is, and the size difference obviously.
As for Crosby to Forsberg, the media is making this comparison lately because of the way Crosby fends off the puck, and I like it. A better one might be Pat Lafontaine though.
Brule to Yzerman fits for me. Brule is that leader I feel, and he plays a very gritty, skilled game. Perhaps the biggest similarity for me though is their shot. Brule has one of the most accurate, unassuming shots you'll ever see in your life. Yzerman did too for years. Brule can pick corners with slap shots from anywhere in the offensive zone, and Stevey Y has always had that ability. Remember that goal Yzerman scored in like, 1998 where he literally scored on the goal line? I remember that was a big highlight goal for years. Pretty sure it's on one of the Don Cherry tapes.
As for Mogilny, I think the best comparison is Zherdev. Zherdev plays a LOT like Mogilny. Sniper with smooth moves, great skater, and a hell of a passing game too.