As a displaced Pittsburgher, now eager Kraken season ticket holder, I wonder what why such negativity pervades here? Bots was a critical part of the construction and development of the Penguins back to back cup teams and did a superior job managing youth and economical talent in Wilkes Barre to supplement a sometimes top-heavy team. Guentzel, Sheary, Rust and others flourished under Bots, and were irreplaceable contributors in the SC runs.
The Pittsburgh organization certainly held him in high regard, inviting him back for the '17 championship celebration even though he had moved on to GM with the Sabres. Speaking of Buffalo, that is one of, if not the very worst situation for a GM in this league. Terrible ownership, doesn't spend smart, decades of disappointment. At least Edmonton has a storied history to be proud of. Buffalo has zero cups in 50 years and wasted the prime of one of the greatest goalies who ever lived. In any case, the BUF reign is hardly the end-all book on Botterill without context, and who knows, maybe his niche is as an assistant GM?
I can't disconnect my affection for Francis from my memories of him as the best two way player in Pens history in his time in our early 90's glory years, but I assume @Myliz could share horror stories from the Carolina experience? I'll remain optimistic in the meantime. So far, the organization has looked pretty polished and top end. Hopefully this translates on the ice?