I think a lot of people really disliked pocklington.
He did a lot of shady shit that hurt a lot of people. Including illegal labor practices, illegal union busting, and even bussing in scabs from Quebec when workers eventually striked. Subsequent losing gainers to bankruptcy after being sued into the ground is part of the reason why those 80s teams were torn apart. He also fired almost all of the oilers hockey ops before selling the team, killing our scouting/ drafting / development for like a decade. Even worse, he wanted to sell the team to Houston; if it wasn't for that smarmy prick Betman the EIG would never have been given a chance to bid.
Also he was just generally kind of an asshat to the fan base in ways worse than even a guy like Lowe. For example, for the 40 year reunion he was asked what kind of fan reception he expected. He replied with something to the effect of "I don't care what the unwashed people of Edmonton think."
Imagine Melnyk situation in Ottawa mixed with
the Ballard situation in Toronto.
And worse yet; as much as the oilers in the DoD were mired in futility, there was atleast hope. The team could afford to pay for players. The team was getting good draft picks. The salary cap atleast had a stabilizing effect where small market low budget teams can theoretically compete.
In the 90s, the oilers entire budget was lower than what a guy like Messier alone was being paid. Every year it was watching the teams best and brightest be traded because we had no hope in being able to actually pay them. Imagine if in the DoD we had a fire sale every year because we couldn't afford to pay competitive contracts.
It really is a shame that Katz wasn't there in the 80s to fund the team.
To be honest, and maybe this is a very basic way to look at it, but I think they could've kept Gretzky and Messier if the owner wasn't bleeding money in other businesses. Surely with Wayne Gretzky the Oilers would've remained the hottest ticket in Canada.
Lets just say the average ticket price circa 1989 for the Oilers was $30 a pop ... at $30 x 17,000 (capacity of Northlands Coliseum) that works out to 510,000 per game and just shy of $21 million for 41 home games. Lets even assume Northlands gets all concession/beer sales.
Add in playoff revenue too, that's probably another $5-$8 million.
Then I think you'd have to factor in merchandise sales, sales from TV rights (CBC, ITV, TSN?), sponsorships ... I mean surely that nets an extra $4-$5 million per year? Have no idea if that's out to lunch or not.
Gretzky's salary in 90-91 at the heyday of the LA Kings experiment was $3 million I believe. Lets say you give Messier $2 million and Kurri $1.8 million ... it still should be enough to have covered their salaries. Of course everyone else would make a good deal less (like $1 mill for Anderson, $1 mill for Fuhr, 500k for Lowe, etc.).
I actually looked up Messier's salary he was only paid $236k (lol) for the 89-90 season where he took the Oilers to the Cup. Even in New York his salary was "only" $2.35 million when they won the Cup in 1994 ... it really doesn't jump into big boy range until 1995-96 when he got 6 million.
Am I way off base here?