I think Andersen needs to play both games,look Tampa lost, which means they are 4 points back with Toronto having a game in hand, a win tomorrow night puts you 6 points up on Tampa and puts the dagger in their playoff chances if they aren't dead already, I mean i don't think they are making up the 4 point difference but you go 6 and it's DONE.
Now the NYI are only 3 points back and if they somehow manage to beat the NYR, which I don't think will happen but if it does they can draw to within 1 point back of us for the wild card.
We can't be messing around with this playoff spot we have to get it locked down and Andersen gives you the best chance to do that
Besides that I see Columbus as a winnable game, I know they are good, you don't get 100 points if you aren't but they still don't scare me as much as the pens, or caps or hawks and the reason is simple.
Columbus is a well rounded solid team however there is no Malkin, or Crosby, or Mcdavid, or Kane or Towes on that team they are not a star studded team I think they are tough but it wouldn't shock me if we beat them or at least got a point tomorrow.
As for NJ we have no business losing to them and the standings are still too close this is a team you should beat you put Andersen in and you get it done.