I'd rather have Yannick Weber as a 3rd line winger or bring AK back. I'd even take Darche or Moen instead of Bourque. Or Leblanc or Geoffrion, if he was healthy.
Bourque had 24 points last year, that shouldn't be that hard to replace.
That's not really the question, otherwise, if we're going to go into what we'd rather have, then I rather have a solid consistent top six a la MaxPac.
What you should be asking yourself is would you rather have Gomez or Bourque. Darche-Weber-LL-whoever else is completely irrelevant.
It's between Gomez and Bourque.
Let's look at the cap hits:
Gomez - 7.357 cap hit for this year +1.
Bourque - 3.333 this year +3.
Now, we're pretty much at 64M in cap hits. If the current offer is accepted (or at least this part agreed on), then next year, the cap will drop back down to 63M (or was it 60?).
Keep in mind, Subban is still unsigned. Because of all these reasons alone, freeing up 7.357 from our cap would be a lot better, even if Gomez only has one extra season left. If we remove Bourque, we're going to get stuck having to move a couple players in order to create space and fit under the cap.
It only makes things simpler.
Also, Bourque looked absolutely horrible last season, but I also think he was completely misused by RC (like pretty much the whole team). You can't make him play along side Plekanec, he can't handle that role. He needs to be either with DD or Eller, getting easier match ups. I'm sure he could do a much better job than last year. We saw how AK could dominate opponents with Eller when facing 3rd liners, I don't see why Bourque wouldn't be able to do the same.
Gomez, on the other hand, has no use. He isn't in our top 3 centers, and he can't fill the role of a 4th line center either. His only chance is to be merged to the wing. The only reason why this is an option is because of our poor winger depth, but we don't know if that transition would work.
However, Gomez has had more than one chance to bounce back and he's failed miserably. Bourque only played 38 games with us, and did so under the supervision of one of the worst coaches I've seen in years.
If you also look at his cap hit, Prust is making 2.5M. Bourque has a friendly cap hit,
Gomez doesn't, and we need room.
It's a no brainer to me. Gomez is out.