- 2012: Andrei Vasilevskiy (Selected 19th overall by the Tampa Bay Lightning)
- 2014: Thatcher Demko (Selected 36th overall by the Vancouver Canucks)
- 2014: Alex Nedeljkovic (Selected 37th overall by the Carolina Hurricanes)
- 2014: Ilya Samsonov (Selected 22nd overall by the Washington Capitals)
- 2015: Mackenzie Blackwood (Selected 42nd overall by the New Jersey Devils)
- 2016: Carter Hart (Selected 48th overall by the Philadelphia Flyers)
- 2018: Jake Oettinger (Selected 26th overall by the Dallas Stars)
- 2018: Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen (Selected 54th overall by the Buffalo Sabres)
- 2020: Yaroslav Askarov (Selected 11th overall by the Nashville Predators)
TBH this list is a bit better than i thought it would be (Demko is good), but is this really your strategy? use your first round pick to try to find the needle in the haystack that comes around 2 or 3 times per decade?
no way man, invest in skaters. goalies are a total crapshoot in today's NHL. we've both said our peace, happy to move on at this point.