mcpw
WPG
- Jan 13, 2015
- 10,024
- 2,072
The one thing I question with your assessment is that it doesn't allow for trying harder. There MAY be several teams that you have dismissed that we could deal with if we are flexible but those kinds of deals are bigger, harder to do and consequently much less likely to happen. I would be willing to try and take back salary fro a cap strapped team or to include a good young piece to a team that doesn't want to trade their youth for our age. That kind of thing obviously has to be limited though.
It's not a final end-all assessment, sure.
What I do believe is that teams who have two competent top4 RDs locked up for a lot of money and term will not be in the game, and that's a final end-all assessment because you don't trade for a player you have zero need for. These include, e. g., MTL (Subban/Petry 14.5M, 6 years), WSH (Carlson/Niskanen 9.75M, 3 years), and NYI (Boychuk/Hamonic 10M, 5 years). That's why I've always shut down any NYI speculation on these boards.
Re cap: Most teams who would have cap issues with Byfuglien do not have these cap issues in 15-16. They will start in 16-17. Columbus is a good example. Just considering 15-16, we could easily take Rene Bourque, maybe even add Jared Boll, and they'd have zero problems fitting Byfuglien under the cap. However, then they will have to extend Byfuglien, Murray, Savard, and Jenner next offseason without any UFAs coming off their books. And that's pretty much impossible. Therefore, we'd have to take a long-term cap dump: Scott Hartnell (productive player still, but I'm not sure I want that contract), or Clarkson (yeah...). And that's the point at which you ask yourself "why do we do this?" Isn't one reason to trade Byfuglien the need for cap space next offseason?
Including a 'good young piece' for a team not wanting to trade youth makes me wonder what the return is like? Byfuglien for a good prospect, we add a good prospect so their rebuild still works, they add a cap dump... now what? Byfuglien+prospect for cap dump+prospect? They're still rebuilding, they won't add a 1st round pick. Or another prospect.