Proposal: Leafs - Wild

[Lapa]

Wild fans. Would you guys deal Alex Stalock or no?

I don't like Stalock that much so in a void yes, but I'd rather keep him for now and let Kähkönen develop properly in the minors. When Kähkönen is ready, you can have Stalock for a 6 pack of Bud Light.

 

[16thOverallSaveUs]

Toronto fans are really funny. Brodin alone gets William Nylander. What part don't you get wild aren't trading young players? My gosh. I am not even sure bill guerin would do Nylander straight up for brodin

You’re lost and making Wild Fans look clueless if you really think Brodin gets Nylander

 

[57special]

Platinum.

 

[MK9]

Johnson
Hollowell
Hutchinson




Donato
Seeler
Rights to Filip Lindberg


Am i way off. I dont know how much Wild value Ryan but he would be exactly what we need IMO. Dont torch me too badly

 

[jaric1862]

in a heartbeat

Hutchinson+4th?

 

[jaric1862]

I don't like Stalock that much so in a void yes, but I'd rather keep him for now and let Kähkönen develop properly in the minors. When Kähkönen is ready, you can have Stalock for a 6 pack of Bud Light.

What if the leafs gave the wild a worse goaltender back, like Hutchinson?

 

[2Pair]

Hutchinson+4th?

Not much interest in Hutchinson, but would still make that trade. You do understand that Stalock is garbage?

 

[Hockeyfan200]

I'd do it in a heart beat. Value is skewed to wild. 1D is over what brodin is (and I love brodin) IMO.

Brodin would be 1d on any team! Brodin has played 1d & 2d pair on wild. The reason wild has been winning again is because Brodreau switched brodin to dumba on 2nd pair as dumba can't play defense to save his life. Literally wild have the best DCore in league with Sutter Spurgeon, Brodin & Dumba as wild top 4

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Not much interest in Hutchinson, but would still make that trade. You do understand that Stalock is garbage?

Stalock is garbage? Haha. Do leafs watch wild at all?

 

[2Pair]

Brodin would be 1d on any team! Brodin has played 1d & 2d pair on wild. The reason wild has been winning again is because Brodreau switched brodin to dumba on 2nd pair as dumba can't play defense to save his life. Literally wild have the best DCore in league with Sutter Spurgeon, Brodin & Dumba as wild top 4

Sutter? Really? Just awful takes all around. When did Suter play on the 2nd pair?

 

[Hockeyfan200]

Sutter? Really? Just awful takes all around. When did Suter play on the 2nd pair?

Read again. Did I say Suter play on 2nd pair? I said wild have 4 of the best dmen. Brodin plays with dumba on 2nd pair

 

[2Pair]

Read again. Did I say Suter play on 2nd pair? I said wild have 4 of the best dmen. Brodin plays with dumba on 2nd pair

You said that Brodin got moved to the 2nd pair to help Dumba. If he "got switched to the 2nd pair" where was he before the switch?

 

[TaLoN]

dumba can't play defense to save his life.

Haven't watched Dumba in 4 years? He's an above avg defender himself these days.

 

[Ciao]

. . . Literally wild have the best DCore in league with Sutter Spurgeon, Brodin & Dumba as wild top 4

Oh. Thanks for telling me. I hadn't noticed.

 

[Hockeyfan200]

You said that Brodin got moved to the 2nd pair to help Dumba. If he "got switched to the 2nd pair" where was he before the switch?

He was with Suter as 1st d pairing. But for two reasons, sutter loves playing with Spurgeon, Brodin got moved to 2nd pair. Also because of dumba struggling early this year they moved brodin to 2nd d pair to help dumba .

 

[Morgs]

Toronto would target the likes of Greenway.
I’d have no problem dealing Nylander for Greenway + Brodin

Okay, well thats because you're literally insane.

 

[2Pair]

He was with Suter as 1st d pairing. But for two reasons, sutter loves playing with Spurgeon, Brodin got moved to 2nd pair. Also because of dumba struggling early this year they moved brodin to 2nd d pair to help dumba .

Brodin hasn't played with Suter since the 14-15 season. Again you say that Brodin was "moved to the 2nd pair early this year". That doesn't ake much sense when he has been on the 2nd pair for the past 5 seasons. Dumba was paired with Brodin because Spurgeon couldn't cut it playing with Brodin. Had nothing to do with "protecting" Dumba and even less to do with anything that concerned Brodin.

Brodin is a very good stay at home defenseman that can hold his own against the best players in the league, but to say that he would be a #1D on any team in the league is nothing more than pure ignorance.

 

[TaLoN]

He was with Suter as 1st d pairing. But for two reasons, sutter loves playing with Spurgeon, Brodin got moved to 2nd pair. Also because of dumba struggling early this year they moved brodin to 2nd d pair to help dumba .

Incorrect. Dumba and Suter were on the top pair. Brodin and Spurgeon were on the second pair.

They moved Dumba to the second pair because Spurgeon and Brodin were downright TERRIBLE to start the season, and they needed to mix things up to see if they could get things back on track.

Both Brodin and Spurgeon's games stabilized after their terrible starts.

Spurgeon needed the boost from our best left defenseman in Suter, Brodin needed the boost from our best right defenseman in Dumba.

 

[Shnooks]

Wild don't really need anyone left wing in Johnson. Why would wild need g Hutchinson? Wild have no room.in Iowa. So why would wild trade 3 players to Toronto 1?

Seeler may not be playing but wild aren't looking to trade him anytime soon. Donate can probably be had but not 1 & 1 for Johnson . Johnson contract isn't better than donato & donato is better right now.

That's funny. Johnsson has more than twice as many goals, and nearly three times as many points, as Donato.

Johnson can also play defense, and penalty kill...while Donato is atrocious in the defensive end.

Donato is nowhere near worth Johnsson...and I'm a fan of neither team.

 

[Shnooks]

Toronto fans are really funny. Brodin alone gets William Nylander. What part don't you get wild aren't trading young players? My gosh. I am not even sure bill guerin would do Nylander straight up for brodin

Then he is going to fail as a GM and isn't very smart.

You should always trade a non-top-pair defenseman for a top-6 forward.

Only thing is, without good centers in Minnesota, Nylander might not be as good as he is in Toronto.

 

[Menzinger]

I don't understand moving AJ for another forward. Just promote a Marlie

 

[Menzinger]

Then he is going to fail as a GM and isn't very smart.

You should always trade a non-top-pair defenseman for a top-6 forward.

Only thing is, without good centers in Minnesota, Nylander might not be as good as he is in Toronto.

Funny enough Nylander is at his best when he is playing centre

 

[dubplatepressure]

That's funny. Johnsson has more than twice as many goals, and nearly three times as many points, as Donato.

Johnson can also play defense, and penalty kill...while Donato is atrocious in the defensive end.

Donato is nowhere near worth Johnsson...and I'm a fan of neither team.

Nah - see he gets paid less and hes younger. So you're wrong. Sorry.

 

[DougGilmour93]

Okay, well thats because you're literally insane.

Is this because you feel Minnesota is giving up too much or you feel Nylander is worth more?

 

[nstarjim]

nylander is worth more than brodin. I don't see the wild adding greenway. also we have zero need for Johnson. Need to loose LW players for Kaprizov spot.