Certainly worthy of a top 3 pick. He’s proven himself at every level, WJC, and college as a true freshman. When’s the last time a freshman dman scored at a 1.19 PPG pace?
LD Zeev Buium - University of Denver, NCAA (2024 Draft)
- Thread starter Pavel Buchnevich
- Start date
Dr Jan Itor
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 40,336
- 35,620
16thOverallSaveUs
Danila Yurov Fan Club Executive Assistant
- May 2, 2018
- 18,794
- 11,752
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
I mean I know you’re familiar but he’s a year younger than Hutson was. He should have been a senior in high school this year.
SlafySZN
Registered User
- May 21, 2022
- 6,733
- 14,455
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
Yeah. His statement was correct. Was just giving context on why I liked Buium season more.
I don’t know where you live but Zeev is a class of ‘24 high school graduate in the States and this statement is patently false. School years aren’t done by birth year like the NHL draft. Kids his age (September and later 05) are just graduating high school next month.
Celebrini just happens to have accelerated and is also young for his class which makes him seem extra young in college.
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 28,947
- 17,106
It wouldn't hurt, and would probably help, Buium to stay one more year in school. You want him to go straight into the NHL, not get cheapshotted in the AHL for a year.
Celbrini is talented as hell, but just so young. It's not just the physical, but the mental maturity for him. Would be nice for him to have another year of maturing in school with kids his own age rather than spending all his time with a bunch of Dads.
Celbrini is talented as hell, but just so young. It's not just the physical, but the mental maturity for him. Would be nice for him to have another year of maturing in school with kids his own age rather than spending all his time with a bunch of Dads.
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 28,947
- 17,106
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
montreal
Go Habs Go
Buium turned 18 9 weeks into the season,
Hutson turned 19 18 weeks into his Freshman year.
Hutson was 18 for almost 90% of his Freshman year and Buium was 17 for say 35% of his Freshman year so about 65% of the time he was 18.
If Buium was born 11 weeks sooner he would have gone in last summers draft.
Hutson turned 19 18 weeks into his Freshman year.
Hutson was 18 for almost 90% of his Freshman year and Buium was 17 for say 35% of his Freshman year so about 65% of the time he was 18.
If Buium was born 11 weeks sooner he would have gone in last summers draft.
August 2005-July 2006
American high school seniors, basically.
Buium more impressive than Hutson because he accelerated
American high school seniors, basically.
Buium more impressive than Hutson because he accelerated
Is this supposed to be meaningful? He wasn’t born on September 16, he was born 3 months after the cutoff.
If he were born less than a month later we wouldn’t even be having this conversation because apparently being born on January 1, 2006 would be visually more impressive for some.
If he born on the same day as me he’d have been eligible for the 1998 draft! Let’s keep these “if he was born on…” tags going! Who gives a crap what % of his freshman year he was 17 or 18…do we think this actually has some merit to him being more or less able to do what he does at this stage?
These are the facts. He’s a class of ‘24 high schooler who is instead destroying college hockey and stepped up his game under the brightest, most intense lights.
Ok. Didn't know that. Here in Western Canada it's January 1, in fact a lot of kids born before February 15 start school a year early. This coming June will see kids born 2006 graduate from grade 12 as well as some kids born before February 15 2007.
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 28,947
- 17,106
There’s that one guy here that insists every draft that every kid with a late birthday should be assessed using the year prior (D -1) tape. I can’t imagine an opinion that would get you laughed out of a scouting room quicker than that.
It isn't uniform. My '04 born child is finishing his 2-year college degree this year while my '06 child is graduating HS this year.
GlassesJacketShirt
Registered User
Not directly related to Buium, but there's a scouting personality here in Quebec who often used the birthdate as the tiebreaker in his draft rankings (Dal Colle > Draisaitl, Laine > Matthews, for example), and man did he get bit in the ass with that as he's been able to admit.
Juxtaposer
Outro: Divina Comedia
My brother is a December birthday and turned 18 during his senior year of high school. Especially for boys, it’s extremely common for parents to enter their sons into school so that they’ll be on the older end of their same-grade peers. Just a few months at that age matters. Buium could easily be a senior in high school this year if his parents had followed that line of thought.
That's not at all the argument I made, but fire away at that strawman.
You don't assess a late birthday ('05 this year) with a normal draft birthyear ('06) based on what the '05 did the previous year (their 17YR old development year) rather you try to predict how the '06 will develop and how they will do in their 18YR old development year (where Buium and other '05s are now).
In simpler terms, scouts get to see Buium play an extra development year before getting to draft him, which is great for Buium since he's taken a massive step forward this year.
Truly unbelievable you fail to grasp this basic concept.
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
Most everyone in the states has Sept 1 or August 15 cutoff. I turned 18 Jan of my senior year.
